The above are excerpted from the book, “The American Ideal of 1776” by Hamilton Abert Long ©1976
The 12 Principles
Principle 12 – The Majority Limited for Liberty
The Principle
1. The traditional American philosophy teaches that The Majority must
be strictly limited in power, and in the operation of government, for
the protection of The Individual’s God-given, unalienable rights
proclaimed in the Declaration of Independence and, therefore, of the
rights of The Minority–of all minorities.
A Restricted Mechanic of Government
2. Self-government’s system of rule by majority vote is based on
necessity. Rule by majority vote is a necessary mechanic of any
government of the popular type, featuring rule by the people through
free, periodic elections such as, for example, those held in the United
States. Under this philosophy, rule by majority vote is always subject
to the “sacred principle” defined in President Jefferson’s First
Inaugural Address, quoted below.
“All, too, will bear in mind this sacred principle, that though
the will of the majority is in all cases to prevail, that will to be
rightful must be reasonable; that the minority possess their equal
rights, which equal law must protect, and to violate would be
oppression.”
A Minority of One Protected
3. The protection provided by this principle applies fundamentally,
of course, in favor of a minority of one: The Individual. No majority,
however great even all of the people but one Individual–may properly
infringe, or possess the power to infringe, the rights of any minority,
however small–even a minority of a lone Individual.
America a Republic–Not a Democracy–In Form of Government–So As to Limit Effectively The Majority To Protect the Individual
4. Therein lies the reason why the American leaders who framed and
ratified the United States Constitution in 1787-1788 chose, for
America’s form of government, that of a Republic and not a Democracy.
(The then existing Confederation was merely a treaty arrangement between
completely independent and separate State governments, by agreement of
their legislatures only and not by consent of the people, with no real
central government–with only a legislative body–and with no power over
those governments or over individual citizens; so it provided no
protection for the rights of The Individual or The Minority against
tyranny by The Majority in any State–later remedied, as to certain
rights, by prohibitions in the original Constitution expressly made
applicable against the States.) A Republic is a constitutionally limited
government of the representative type, created by a written
Constitution–adopted by the people and changeable (from its original
meaning) by them only by its amendment–with its powers divided between
three separate Branches: Executive, Legislative and Judicial. In a
Republic, the whole system is designed primarily to protect The
Individual’s unalienable rights–therefore The Minority, all
minorities–against any violation by government or by others. As the
Declaration of Independence expresses this American goal of safeguarding
these rights, the people form their governments “to secure these
rights”–to make and keep them secure.
The Majority Omnipotent in Any Democracy
5. This is not the case under a Democracy, speaking of it as a form
of government and not merely in the more general sense of its meaning a
popular type of government. In a Democracy, The Majority is omnipotent,
whether it be a Representative Democracy or a Direct Democracy. In the
Representative type, the people function governmentally through an
elected legislature, which selects and controls the head of the
Executive Department, as in Great Britain where “the authority of the
parliament is transcendent and uncontrolable” (as stated in The
Federalist number 53, by Madison)–where in fact the House of Commons
alone has by law become supreme. In the Direct type, all of the
electorate (those entitled to vote) assemble as a single group to debate
and decide directly and conclusively all governmental questions. This
is suitable only for a very small number of people–as in a New England
town with a town-meeting system of government, or in a situation like
that of the small city-states of ancient Greece. (Decisions of a New
England town-meeting are, of course, subject to the State and United
States Constitutions which protect the rights of The Individual and The
Minority, so such a town-meeting government is not a true Democracy
featuring The Majority Omnipotent.)
In a Democracy, The Individual Is Subservient and Must Be Submissive to The Omnipotent Majority
6. Any Democracy, either Representative or Direct, does not even
recognize the existence of any unqualified rights of The Individual,
much less his possessing God-given, unalienable rights as conceived by
the American philosophy. A Democracy in America, as a form of
government, would therefore provide no protection for these rights.
Under a Democracy, Man is considered to have only qualified privileges
permitted by The Majority in control of government and revocable by it
at any time. This spells Rule by Omnipotent Majority, with The
Individual and The Minority as well as all minorities victimized at the
pleasure of The Majority, without limit and without any legal basis for
objection or practical remedy. The idea of such unlimited rule, as if by
“divine right of The Majority,” is as abhorrent in the eyes of the
traditional American philosophy as is the idea of rule by “divine right
of kings.”
The Uniquely American Principle Was Thoroughly Understood in 1776
7. The traditional American philosophy requires a Republic’s
constitutionally limited form of government for the security of Man’s
unalienable rights against violation by The Majority, by government, as
well as by others. This philosophy was well understood in America in
1776 but was imperfectly practiced by the States in the post-1776
period, during which rights were violated. This correct understanding
was exemplified by the previously noted (Par. 8, Principle 2)
town-meeting petition of Pittsfield, Massachusetts, addressed to the
legislature of Massachusetts in May, 1776. It urged the adoption by the
people–as “the fountain of power”–of a Constitution as their fundamental
law, to fill the void created by the end of royal rule, as “the first
step to be taken” by the people in order to guard against
despotism–against “the wanton exercise of power”–and it asserted, that
the only safeguard is “the formation of a fundamental constitution” by
the people. Their aim was to safeguard their liberties. This was
accomplished by the people of Massachusetts in 1780, by their creating
the first true Constitution and Republic in the world. They utilized
successfully, for the first time in history, a constitutional
convention–which is America’s great, if not greatest, contribution to
the mechanics of self-government through constitutional government.
(Earlier Acts of Legislatures of other States were erroneously
classified as “constitutions,” while some countries’ governments
throughout history had generally been erroneously classified as
“republics”–a much-misunderstood and loosely used term. See the correct
definition of a Republic in Paragraph 4, above.)
Principle Violated by “Elective Despotism” after 1776
8. The post-1776 period witnessed gross violations by State
Legislatures of the unalienable rights of victimized Individuals. In
Virginia, for example, Jefferson protested vigorously against the
Legislature’s acts of tyranny by The Majority, stating: “An elective
despotism was not the government we fought for (“Notes on The State of
Virginia,” 1782; emphasis Jefferson’s). Misconduct in this period by The
Omnipotent Majority in the legislatures of a number of the States was
in reaction against the earlier oppressive rule by the king and his
royal governors and judges. At that time, except in Massachusetts under
its Constitution of 1780, there were no real State Constitutions to
restrain the legislatures, which made sure that the governors and judges
were without power to prohibit legislative enactments (by which the
violations of unalienable rights were effected). The New Hampshire
Constitution, based on this pattern, was not adopted until 1784 after a
Constitutional Convention was successful in framing one acceptable to
the people–several earlier conventions having been unsuccessful. Other
States did not follow suit for a number of years, some not for decades.
“The Excesses of Democracy”
9. This type of tyranny, by Omnipotent Majority, is always possible
under any Democracy as a form of government. This is what The Framers
and Ratifiers of the Constitution and their fellow American leaders
meant when, in the 1787-1788 debates with regard to the framing and
adoption of the Constitution, they denounced the 11 excesses of
democracy. They were, of course, not criticizing popular government as
such–for instance as it exists under the Republic of the United States
featuring constitutionally limited government, as limited by the
Constitution. They were, therefore, not condemning democracy in the
general sense of the term–meaning merely a popular type of government.
They were speaking in support of America’s being a Republic, not a
Democracy, as a form of government. The more general meaning of
Democracy–popular government–also applies to America; but this use of
the term is only confusing in any discussion, as here, of the
characteristics of different forms of popular government: a Republic in
contrast to a Democracy.
Federal and State Republics
10. The foregoing explains why the traditional American philosophy
requires that the central (Federal) government and the State governments
be Republics. (See Pars. 6-7 of Principle 5.) Each State is guaranteed
the form of government of a Republic by the United States Constitution
(Art. IV, Sec. 4). The foregoing also makes clear why this philosophy
requires that The Majority, at any time in temporary charge of
government, administer its affairs in keeping with the Constitution’s
limitations and for the benefit of all Individuals composing the people
as a whole, meaning The Minority and all minorities as well as The
Majority–not merely for the benefit of those constituting only The
Majority of the moment.
The Conclusion
11. The traditional American philosophy demands that the power of The
Majority be limited for the protection of The Individual’s unalienable
rights, for the security of Man’s Liberty against Government-over-Man,
in keeping with the American formula: The Majority–Limited for Liberty.
Principle 11 – Taxes Limited to Safeguard Liberty
The Principle
1. The traditional American philosophy teaches that tyranny through
taxation is one of the most dangerous and oppressive aspects of
Government-over-Man and must be guarded against and opposed accordingly,
for the protection of Man’s God-given, unalienable rights.
The Precedent of 1776
2. Tyrannous abuse of the taxing power was a principal provocation of
the American Revolution in 1776 and, according to this philosophy, will
always be considered and treated as just cause for prompt, effective,
remedial action by every generation of Americans worthy of the American
heritage of Individual Liberty–the heritage of Free Man determined to
preserve his Freedom from Government-over-Man. This can be done mainly
through preserving inviolate the supporting system of constitutionally
limited government, designed to restrict government’s activities and
therefore its cost and taxes.
Limited Taxing Power
3. The traditional American philosophy of constitutionally limited
government–Limited for Liberty–is hostile to any concept which would
permit any unlimited power of taxation to exist to the peril of Man’s
unalienable rights. Potential danger, not merely present danger, is the
crux of the matter and the reason for constitutional safeguards, which
are designed to provide protection in the worst imaginable situations.
This philosophy prescribes various limitations upon the taxing power of
the Federal government, as expressed in the Constitution. For example,
Article 1, Section 8, of the Constitution authorizes Congress to make
only specified levies–within the bounds of certain specific limits as to
uses of tax monies: “to pay the Debts and provide for the common
Defence and general Welfare of the United States.” It also authorizes
taxes only to raise revenue to pay for the government’s authorized
activities, within the bounds of its limited powers and limited duties
under the Constitution, as amended–for use directly and openly to
accomplish the objects committed to its care and the trusts for which it
is made responsible by the people under this basic law. This is
according to the controlling intent of those who framed and ratified the
Constitution in 1787-1788, and likewise as to each amendment.
Examples of What Is Not Authorized
4. A few examples of what is not authorized by the Constitution in
this regard, therefore as impliedly prohibited, will be clarifying. In
general, the power of taxation may not be used by the Federal government
as a means of bringing about indirectly and subtly any governmental
change, or any social or other type of reform, or to achieve indirectly
in effect Federal control of anything or anybody, or to accomplish any
other result whatever, which the people have not authorized by the
Constitution to be accomplished directly and openly. Nor may the power
of taxation be used in furtherance of any abuse of the limited powers
granted to the Federal government, or in furtherance of activities due
to usurpation of any power withheld from it, or denied or prohibited to
it, expressly or impliedly, by the people through the Constitution, as
amended.
It is especially noteworthy that Hamilton, as Secretary of the
Treasury, in urging for the first time in 1791 that the Taxing Clause
granted to the Federal government a separate and substantive power for
the application of money, “within the limits of what would serve the
general welfare,” conceded that such power would “not carry a power to
do any other thing not authorized in the Constitution, either expressly
or by fair implication.” (See Pars. 8-10 of Principle 5.)
Some specific examples are as follows. The power of taxation may not
be used so as to prevent criticism of the Federal government by the
Press; which would be exercising power over a field of activity withheld
from this government by the original Constitution and expressly
prohibited by the First Amendment. Nor may taxes be used to obtain funds
to subsidize, and in effect to control, any field of activity denied to
this government (excluded from its enumerated powers) and reserved to
the States by the Constitution–so as in effect to “buy” submission to
Federal usurpers: such as agriculture. Hamilton made it expressly clear,
in The Federalist number 17, that this is a field of activity over
which the Federal government had been given no power–a field over which
it could never properly be given any power to control. Also, taxes may
not be used to stifle, undermine, or destroy any part of the traditional
American system’s economic aspect of Liberty such as Individual
Enterprise (individual, private, competitive, enterprise).
Equally repugnant and prohibited are taxes designed to put into
effect the anti-private-property idea, or plan, of “leveling” of
ownership of property (money or any other type) by attempting to make
all people more “equal” as to property, or as to income, by taking from
some to give to others–as a means of achieving social reform or any
other purpose not directly and openly authorized by the people in the
Constitution. For example, in 1768 a Resolution of the Massachusetts
House of Representatives (drafted by James Otis, Samuel Adams et al)
denounced such leveling as being “despotic and . . . unconstitutional.”
Two decades later The Federalist (number 10, by Madison) condemned it as
“improper” and “wicked.” Jefferson decried leveling as being unjust and
violative of “the first principle of association”–meaning a people’s
associating for purposes of self-government.
The Examples Continued
5. Congress is not authorized to tax and spend as it pleases, for any
and every purpose which it may choose to say, or actually thinks, will
serve the “general welfare.” Those who framed and ratified the
Constitution in 1787-1788 intended the Taxing Clause’s words: “general
Welfare of the United States,” to serve as a limitation on the taxing
power. These words were designed to restrict taxing and spending to
constitutionally authorized objectives, meaning in part only those which
would serve the welfare of the United States as a whole and not merely
of a locality, not of individual citizens. Congress does not possess
unlimited, sovereign power to tax the people. (See Pars. 8-10 of
Principle 5.) It does not even possess “general legislative authority,
as Hamilton stated in The Federalist number 83.
Congress has, of course, been granted no power to exceed its
constitutional authority or responsibilities by being benevolent, by
making donations, of money or property at home or abroad at the expense
of the American people’s income, or other money or property. According
to the controlling intent of those who framed and ratified the
Constitution, the only words in the Taxing Clause which could possibly
be said to sanction any donation to any foreign government, or people,
are the words “national defense”–meaning direct and actual military
defense of the American homeland. Any and all foreign donations by the
Federal government are, therefore, clearly prohibited by inescapable
implication unless, and except to the limited extent that any such
donation in actuality helps directly and substantially, on a realistic
military basis, to “provide for the common Defence . . . of the United
States”–of the States composing the Union.
These few illustrations exemplify prohibited misuse of the limited
taxing power as granted by the people to the Federal government under
the Constitution, as amended.
Peril to Liberty–Multiplied
6. The traditional American philosophy recognizes that an unlimited
power to tax involves the power to destroy–a truth long known. This
becomes all the more evilly significant if, when and to the extent that
the Federal government becomes guilty of wholesale usurpation of power
to expand its activities, at home and abroad, in defiance of the limits
on its power imposed by the sovereign people through the Constitution.
The evil significance involved is greatly augmented when–in furtherance
of such wholesale usurpation–any such official culprits: Federal
usurpers, employ oppressive taxation so as in effect to finance their
political schemes to keep themselves in power, in control of the
government, by using vast sums of public monies to subsidize–in truth to
bribe, corrupt and seduce–immense segments of the electorate through
distribution of individual money “benefits”, to win their votes. This
aim and process are furthered by building up a vast governmental
bureaucracy which helps to serve this objective but has no sensible
relation to sound governmental operations serving constitutionally
authorized purposes. Then, indeed, are Individual Liberty and sound
self-government in America–also the integrity and safety of the Republic
itself–placed in effect on the auction block. This potentially
disastrous condition, of danger compounded, becomes almost unlimited in
degree of peril for Free Man in America, for American Posterity, when
this combination of usurpation and tax tyranny is employed–by such
usurpers and their collaborators in all walks of life–to supplant the
traditional American system of Man-over-Government with the system of
Government-over-Man. The foregoing precepts reflect some aspects of The
Founders’ thinking in this connection. (Note especially the Jefferson
quotation on page xx, ante, about taxing–spending–electing.) Any
accomplishment of the prohibited objectives by gradual and deceptive
steps–rather than directly and openly–highlights the importance of
keeping ever in mind a maxim of which the sense was well-known to them
and is expressable in verse form as follows:
Great Oaks and Great Tyrannies
Just as surely as “great oaks from little acorns grow,”
So do greatest tyrannies have smallest beginnings;
Yet the mind, uninstructed by knowledge or reason,
Cannot sense either oak or tyranny in the seed.
No Unlimited Income-Tax Power Under the Principle of Limited Government
7. The foregoing holds good even though the traditional American
philosophy and system contemplate the Federal government’s possessing,
by grant of the people under the Constitution, “an unqualified power of
taxation in the ordinary modes,” as stated in The Federalist (number 31,
by Alexander Hamilton)–for instance, a consumption tax on sales of
goods. Such a tax cannot become dangerous to the people’s liberties
because it contains an automatic check on abuse by way of such taxation;
if the amount of the tax offends them, they can simply refuse to buy
the goods and thereby make the tax a failure, leading to its repeal.
Even “an unqualified power of taxation” in some mode which was not
ordinary in the days of The Founders and was not provided for by them in
the Constitution–for instance, a graduated, “escalating” income tax,
especially without expressly specifying a maximum rate or
“ceiling”–would nevertheless have been considered by them to be
impliedly limited in effect because subject to the following factors.
First, the principles proclaimed in the Declaration of
Independence–notably that governments are granted only “just powers,”
meaning limited powers, in order to make and keep secure the people’s
unalienable rights–forbid the existence in America of any system of
government or governmental practices which could, in effect and in the
unlimited discretion of public servants, impose tax-slavery upon the
people through permitting these public, servants in peacetime to
confiscate most, or all, of the income of the people to be spent as
these public servants may please. This assuredly would have been
considered by The Founders to be the very definition of tax-tyranny,
which was one of the chief causes of the Revolution in 1776. Second, the
system intended to be created by The Framers and Adopters of the
Constitution–with only the few, limited powers enumerated being granted
to the Federal government (for example, per The Federalist number 45 by
Madison with Hamilton’s silent concurrence)–likewise bars tax-tyranny
because Congress is authorized to tax and spend only within the scope of
its power-limits and its commensurately limited responsibilities; which
must always be construed in keeping with that original, controlling
intent of The Framers and Adopters, subject only to amendment by the
people of the Constitution. Congress may not tax and spend in support of
activities in furtherance of abuse of any granted power or in support
of usurpation of power not granted.
The Founders would assuredly have stressed these implied limits upon
any power to tax incomes of the people–if granted by and constitutional
amendment–in the absence of an express, specific and clear mandate from
the people to the contrary stated in any such amendment, for instance if
it should expressly authorize confiscatory taxes for war needs. Just as
they certainly would have condemned any generation of Americans as
being unfaithful to the American heritage of Man-over-Government, as
being defaulting trustees of Posterity’s just heritage, because of any
submission to oppressive taxation amounting to tax-tyranny. This applies
equally to taxation of accumulated wealth (savings), or property, by
way of inheritance, or estate. taxes (death taxes), which are equally
subject to the above-mentioned principles and implied limits.
The basic American principles previously discussed: “Limited and
Decentralized for Liberty” (per Principles 5 and 6) would therefore,
have been declared by The Founders to be respected and protected in
effect and impliedly by pertinent, controlling limitations despite any
income-tax, or any death-tax, provision in any amendment to the
Constitution not expressly fixing a maximum rate or “ceiling.” They
would have agreed that the above-mentioned implied limits would
nevertheless be applicable, though not made express, so as to bar
unlimited taxing-power opening the door to tax-tyranny, tax-slavery.
Benjamin Franklin’s Example
8. When government takes a part of an Individual’s earned income,
this is the equivalent of government’s commandeering, or confiscating,
for its own purposes a corresponding portion of his working time; he is
deprived of the benefit, of the fruit, of such work and time. A
taxpayer’s time is employed in the service, or support, of government to
the extent that be must devote it to earning the money required to pay
the taxes imposed by government. Benjamin Franklin suggested a specific
standard or rule by which to judge the character of taxation, presumably
in peacetime (not in a national crisis of war), as to whether or not it
is oppressive and beyond which the burden of taxation would, in his
opinion, presumably have been considered oppressive, if not tyrannous.
It was stated by him in a 1758 writing:
“It would be thought a hard Government that should tax its People
one tenth Part of their Time, to be employed in its Service.” (Emphasis
his.)
(Maximum income-tax rate was only seven per cent under [the] 1913 law–the first under the Sixteenth Amendment.)
Under the American philosophy and system of constitutionally limited
government, there is and always must be some limit, express or implied,
as a standard beyond which the people may properly, indeed should,
consider peacetime taxation to amount to impermissible confiscation and
therefore oppression and tax-tyranny. Otherwise a mockery is made of the
fundamental American principle of limited government. One general test
which is unchallengeable, under a system of constitutionally limited
government, is this: any and every aspect of taxation which is designed
to provide financial support for any governmental activity which
involves abuse of granted power, or usurpation of ungranted power,
merits condemnation as tax-tyranny.
The Conclusion
9. It is a cardinal principle of the traditional American philosophy
that taxes must be limited to safeguard Individual Liberty–to make and
keep secure Man’s unalienable rights and Posterity’s just heritage of
Liberty: Freedom from Government-over-Man.
Principle 10 – Private Property: Liberty’s Support
The Principle
1. The traditional American philosophy teaches that Man possesses the
right to property as an indispensable support, the principal material
support, of his God-given, unalienable rights (notably the right to
Liberty) specified in the Declaration of Independence.
Part of Economic Liberty
2. This right to property is a main part of economic liberty, which
is the inseparable and indispensable aspect of the indivisible whole of
Individual Liberty, according to this philosophy. Without economic
liberty, the other parts of Individual Liberty are lacking in material
support and therefore, for practicable purposes, cannot be defended
adequately or securely enjoyed enduringly. This right to property in any
form–money or any other type–includes all aspects such as acquiring,
using, possessing, protecting and disposing of it. Man’s unalienable
right to Life necessarily involves his derivative right to property, in
support of his right to sustain his own life and the lives of his
dependents; which requires, in part, acquiring and using food and
various other kinds of property necessary to existence or conducive to
full enjoyment of God-given, unalienable rights in varied and
innumerable ways.
The Underlying Reason
3. The American philosophy teaches that the fact that Man is endowed
by his Creator with the Right to be self-governing, as the Declaration
of Independence proclaims, means implicitly that Man is also endowed
with the capacity to reason and, therefore, with the capacity to be
self-governing–under a system of Man-over-Government–for the better
protection and enjoyment of his unalienable rights. This, in turn, means
necessarily that Man is endowed with the capacity of being economically
self-reliant and independent, without the need of being supported by
his creature and tool: government. This is true because to be supported
by government would mean to be subject to its control under a system of
Government-over-Man; control inevitably accompanies subsidy. As part of
his Divine endowment at birth, Man therefore possesses both the right
and the capacity to manage his own economic affairs, including his own
capability to work in order to support life and his rights in general by
acquiring property (money or any other type), free from any degree of
Government-over-Man control, directly or indirectly. Any contrary
conclusion would inescapably, condemn Man to a birthright of servitude
to government, which philosophy rejects as being inconsistent with
Divine Creation. This philosophy also teaches that Man is entitled to
enjoy this right and to exercise this capability without any
interference by others than government as well. The foregoing is
subject, of course, to due respect for the equal rights of others and
for just laws expressive of “just powers” (to quote the term of the
Declaration of Independence) designed to safeguard the equal rights of
all Individuals.
The View of The Framers, per “The Federalist”
4. The American philosophy is clear and emphatic on the point that
the surest way for Man to become economically dependent upon, and
therefore subservient to, government is for it to control or possess his
property, or to subsidize him. This is because of the truth stated in
The Federalist (number 79, by Alexander Hamilton) that: “In the general
course of human nature, a power over a man’s subsistence amounts to a
power over his will.” (Emphasis Hamilton’s) This truth is also commonly
acknowledged in the maxim that “he who pays the piper calls the tune”
and it applies especially to a person’s income.
The Means of Self-defense
5. This is all the more true to the extent that government controls,
or takes from him, his property–not only his current earnings, or
income, but also his accumulated savings represented by his property in
general. The more government controls or takes from him, and the less
Man possesses and controls, the worse his plight in the face of
Government-over-Man practices infringing his unalienable rights. This
deprives him of the means of self-defense, of defense of his rights,
against violations by government and by others. Lacking such means, his
rights are always in danger of being violated or undermined with
impunity by transgressors–either oppressive or usurping government
officials, or covetously inclined persons who are disregardful of the
limits on their own equal rights and are heedless of the duty factor of
Individual Liberty-Responsibility, which requires them to respect the
equal rights of others.
Property Needed for Defense of Man’s Rights
6. According to the American philosophy, Man’s purpose in creating
governments is primarily “to secure”–to make and keep secure–his
unalienable rights, as the Declaration of Independence phrases it. A
chief aim of man in this regard is to provide governmental (legal)
machinery which can be readily available to each Individual for
establishing and maintaining his legal right to his own property and for
the equal protection of all Individuals’ property under equal laws
(basically the people’s fundamental laws–their Constitutions, Federal
and State). To be able to make effective use of this legal machinery,
however, Man needs property (money) to pay the cost.
The 1776 Declaration and the Word “Property”
7. In the years leading up to the American Revolution of 1776, the
slogan of the “Sons of Liberty”–most ardent of patriots–was: “Liberty
and property.” Another popular phrase used throughout America in that
period to describe Man’s most precious rights, used for example in the
“Declaration and Resolves of the First Continental Congress” in 1774,
was: “life, liberty and property.” This combination of ideas–expressed
with regard to protection of Man’s ” . . . life . . . person . . . goods
or estate . . .”–appeared in America at least by 1641 in Massachusetts
in: “The Body of Liberties.” This was a law code compiled by Nathaniel
Ward, in response to public protests against the arbitrary decisions by
judges, and adopted by the Massachusetts General Court, the legislative
body of the colony. In the phrase of the Declaration of Independence
adopted in 1776–“Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness” – the
substitution of the phrase “the pursuit of Happiness,” in place of the
word “property” customarily used theretofore, assuredly did not mean
that the signers of the Declaration disapproved of the idea of the right
to property being considered a most important right of Man. Quite the
contrary is true, as all pertinent records amply prove. A number of
these signers were owners of large and valuable property holdings–for
example, John Hancock, Thomas Jefferson, Robert Morris, Charles Carroll,
Richard Henry Lee and Arthur Middleton, to name only a few. They did,
indeed, risk great fortunes, as well as their lives and honor, in
signing the 1776 Declaration–as its closing pledge made express, in
words made immortal by the exemplary selflessness, the noble
self-sacrifice, of these true friends of Independence for America and of
Man’s Liberty against Government-over-Man. The wealthy of that
generation were fully matched by those of little or no means, such as
Samuel Adams, in the fervor of belief in, and support of, the right to
property as a fundamental part of the Individual’s rights. It is
noteworthy that among the signers of the Declaration were some who had
been members of the above-mentioned First Continental Congress in 1774;
and all the signers undoubtedly shared the then popular support of the
slogan: “Life, Liberty and Property” as being expressive of the gist of
Man’s fundamental rights. The emphasis in their thinking regarding the
right to property was later reflected in the safeguarding provision
included in the “Bill of Rights” amendments to the United States
Constitution–in the Fifth Amendment, stating: “. . . nor shall private
property be taken for public use, without just compensation.” This is
expressive of the American philosophy.
The omission of the word “property” from the 1776 Declaration was,
presumably, because the right to property was considered by America’s
leaders in general to be not a primary, God-given, unalienable right–not
on a par spiritually with the right to “Life, Liberty and the pursuit
of Happiness”–but an essential legal right, a most important supporting
right as the material mainstay of Man’s unalienable rights including
Liberty against Government-over-Man.
An Essential Means, Not an End in and of Itself
8. The right to property is accordingly considered not an end, in and
of itself, but an indispensable means needed to sustain Life itself and
for the protection and fuller enjoyment of the rights to Liberty and
the pursuit of Happiness. The right to property is, therefore, of
critical importance to Free Man, whether considered as a supporting
right or–as some in 1776 occasionally referred to it–as an unalienable
right, a Natural Right.
The concept of the property right being derived from every
Individual’s natural right to Liberty–of its thus being a derivative
right rather than a primary, God-given, unalienable right–was expressed
for example in an oration in Boston on March 5, 1775 by Dr. Joseph
Warren, a leader among the more prominent workers and fighters for
Liberty and Independence, as follows:
“That personal freedom is the natural right of every man, and
that property, or an exclusive right to dispose of what he has honestly
acquired by his own labor, necessarily arises therefrom, are truths
which common sense has placed beyond the reach of contradiction.”
(Emphasis added.)
Warren and his fellow leaders in favor of “Liberty and Independence,”
in Boston especially in that pre-1776 period, were undoubtedly in
agreement on this point of derivativeness: “necessarily arises
therefrom”–notably Samuel Adams who was very closely associated with
Warren in supporting this cause. Adams presumably meant nothing
different when he sometimes referred to the right to property as being
of the nature of a “Natural Right.”
Property Supports Ideals
9. Man’s right to property is the principal material support of the
idealism of the traditional American philosophy–the idealism of Free Man
in America. This idealism would be empty of substance in the absence of
the protection provided by such support; it could not be translated
into reality and sustained enduringly.
The Conclusion
10. The American philosophy asserts that Man’s right to property is a
main, indispensable and inseparable part of the indivisible whole of
Individual Liberty-Responsibility and the material mainstay of his
unalienable right to “Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.”
Principle 9 – Liberty Against Government Over Man
The Principle
1. The traditional American philosophy teaches that the God-given,
unalienable right of Man to “Liberty” means primarily Freedom from
Government-over-Man–or, otherwise stated, Liberty against
Government-over-Man.
The Broader Definition
2. This is the primary meaning of the word “Liberty” as used in the
Declaration of Independence and in the Preamble of the United States
Constitution. In this fundamental law of the people, The Framers sought
to translate into enduring governmental reality, to the maximum
practicable extent, the ideals and principles of that 1776 Declaration.
They stated in the Preamble the goals to be served by the central
(Federal) government in its use of the powers granted to it by the
people, as enumerated in the body of that basic law. The word “Liberty”
also means, of course, freedom of The Individual from interference or
coercion by other Individuals in the enjoyment of his unalienable rights
and of the supporting rights. Individual Liberty is an indivisible
whole.
Liberty-Responsibility
3. According to this philosophy, Liberty must always be taken to mean
Individual Liberty-Responsibility, with emphasis upon the duty of
respecting the equal rights of others and just laws expressive of “just
powers” (to quote the term of the Declaration of Independence) designed
to safeguard the equal rights of all Individuals. Individual
Liberty-Responsibility involves the self-governing Individual’s being
burdened with the duties underlying his share of the responsibility for
their safety of the Liberty of all Individuals, and of their other
unalienable rights. Lacking such a sense of responsibility, Liberty can
readily degenerate into license. Individual Liberty-Responsibility
denotes that challenging freedom which tests the courage and wisdom of
Free Man because of the truth that:
Only the brave dares to be–only the wise can remain–Free Man
By accepting the challenge, performing the duties, of
Individual Liberty-Responsibility under constitutionally limited government.
Freedom of Choice
4. The Liberty of Free Man is basically the Liberty of freedom of
choice, with due respect for the equal rights of others. Without this
freedom, Man cannot really be free, nor can there be any moral value or
merit in his actions because they are not voluntary, not a true
self-expression, not based on unfettered election between right and
wrong, between good and evil, in the light of conscience and his
personal moral code. An example of freedom of choice is freedom of
association–for instance, freedom to join, or not to join, any
particular organization (such as an organization of employers or of
employees) without compulsion by government or by any others. This means
any organization for a lawful purpose–not a conspiracy to commit
murder, for example, and not a conspiratorial, subversive organization
such as the Kremlin-controlled Communist (“Party”) conspiracy which aims
to subvert the United States government and all other American
governments as well as to destroy all traditional American values; as to
which the overt act of joining the conspiracy is the main factor
creating guilt by association of persons, not of ideas. (Discussed also
in Par. 6 of Principle 4 and Par. 9 of Principle 7.)
The “Self” Factors of Free Men
5. Liberty means Man’s freedom which characterizes a wisely and
soundly self-governing people, determined to live up fully to high
ideals in the enjoyment of The Individual’s rights and in the
performance of the accompanying duties defined by these essential
elements of the philosophy of truly Free Man:
(1) the spiritual: self-respect; (2) the economic: self-reliance; (3) the political-social: self-discipline.
These are the “self” factors characteristic of the self-governing and genuine Free Man.
Self-respect
6. Fundamentally, self-respect stems from Man’s realization of the
truth that the Spiritual is supreme and that he is of Divine creation,
therefore possessed of a spiritual nature; and that The Individual is
therefore of supreme dignity and value. Self-respect is fostered and
evidenced by The Individual’s striving to maintain the integrity of his
unalienable rights. This is manifested partly by insisting that
government as well as others respect them–in keeping with the
requirements of constitutionally limited government. It is further
manifested by his dedication to his own unceasing growth in the fuller
realization of his own highest potential–spiritually, morally and
intellectually, in every aspect of life.
Self-reliance
7. Self-reliance in the economic field–of the essence of Individual
Liberty-Responsibility–is an essential characteristic of Free Man. This
is true because dependence upon government for economic support
inescapably saps the independence of Man’s spirit, robs him of the
inspiration and inclination to be individually venturesome and
self-reliant, and undermines his willingness and capacity to oppose
developments of a Government-over-Man nature including violation by
government of the unalienable rights of himself and others. Such
violation can be brought about by use of force, or by inducement through
subsidy by government which is inescapably accompanied by control. As
The Federalist (number 79, by Alexander Hamilton) soundly states: “In
the general course of human nature, a power over a man’s subsistence
amounts to a power over his will.” (Emphasis Hamilton’s.) This truth, in
keeping with the adage that “he who pays the piper calls the tune” as
well as with the dictates of common sense born of experience, was
acknowledged by the United States Supreme Court when it stated (1936
Butler case) that: “The power to confer or withhold unlimited benefits
is the power to coerce or destroy.” Firm belief in the supreme value of
Liberty–to the complete subordination always of economic security to
Liberty’s well-being–and consistent action in support of this belief,
are always chief characteristics of every American who is worthy of his
heritage of Free Man.
Self-discipline
8. Self-discipline involves, in main part, The Individual’s faithful
performance of the duties underlying Individual Liberty-Responsibility,
in keeping with the truth that there can be no Right apart from Duty, no
Liberty or Freedom apart from Responsibility. The self-discipline of
the self-governor is the alternative to being disciplined and controlled
by government. Self discipline by The Individual, by respecting the
boundary line separating his rights from the equal rights of others,
provides the requisite moral basis for prohibiting violation by them of
his own rights. Self-discipline, in the political-social realm, is a
principle characteristic of Free Man among Free Men in an enduring and
ethical environment of freedom. This is the only environment in which
Individual Liberty can be secure and flourish.
As to each Individual among a self-governing people under
constitutionally limited government, self-discipline involves
self-control with regard to making demands upon government. The inherent
duties require that nothing be done to help induce government to
violate the limits of its powers or corresponding responsibilities as
defined in the people’s fundamental law: the Constitution, regardless of
any seeming benefits temporarily. Such sound conduct is required, in
part, in order to help to influence others soundly by proper example in
keeping with the moral precept that, in this limited but important sense
as to things governmental, each Individual is his “brother’s keeper.”
Liberty’s Two-fold Meaning
9. Liberty is expressive of that within Free Man which reflects the
essence of his mind and spirit–of his very soul, in the religious sense
implicit in the uniquely American concept of Man’s being endowed by his
creator with unalienable rights. This is what was meant when American
leaders of 1776-1787 used the word “Liberty”–for instance, Patrick Henry
in his famed cry “Give me liberty or give me death.” This is what was
meant by Benjamin Franklin in his profoundly true statement in 1759
that: “They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little
temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.” Such convictions
typify Americans. These spokesmen for Free Man in America meant
primarily Man’s Liberty against Government-over-Man. Included also, of
course, is Man’s right to freedom from violation of his rights by others
than government–by any person, group or organization. The “safety” to
which Franklin referred can soundly be said to include also the economic
aspect: economic security provided by government–always involving
sacrifice of Liberty, in varying degree, however subtle or disguised.
The Lofty Challenge
10. The signers of the Declaration of Independence elevated Patrick
Henry’s glowing expression of this loftiest of sentiments regarding
Liberty to the highest reaches of the human mind and spirit when they
closed this 1776 Declaration’s uniquely American message, to American
Posterity and to all mankind, with these immortal words:
“And for the support of this Declaration, with a firm reliance on
the protection of divine Providence, we mutually pledge to each other
our Lives, our Fortunes, and our Sacred Honor.”
On a similarly high plane, President Washington’s First Inaugural
Address defined the great opportunity and responsibility of the American
people – as custodians of Individual Liberty-Responsibility in
history’s first example of a soundly conceived and adequately founded
Republic (defined, for example, in Par. 6 of Principle 5) embracing an
entire country and its people. His inspiring words were:
“. . . the preservation of the sacred fire of liberty. and the
destiny of the Republic model of Government, are justly considered as
deeply, perhaps as finally stated, on the experiment entrusted to the
hands of the American people.” (Emphasis Washington’s)
(True Republics had been formed in Mass., 1780, and N.H., 1784.) This
profound message to all generations of Americans emphasizes their true
role and opportunity in relations with other peoples: to seek to
influence them chiefly by sound example, as successful self-governors
ever faithful to the Constitution’s spirit and letter, as never
faltering Friends of Individual Liberty–of Man’s Freedom from
Government-over-Man.
The Conclusion
11. The American philosophy teaches that Individual Liberty is
indivisible and for one and all, or for none, in the long run–that the
American choice is: Individual Liberty in full, for one and all, always.
Principle 8 – Life and the Pursuit of Happiness
The Principle
1. The traditional American philosophy teaches that the words “Life”
and “the pursuit of Happiness,” as used in the Declaration of
Independence, are so inclusive as to defy precise definition.
Ever Changing Nature of Goals, etc.
2. This is because they mean the right to Life to be lived, and
Happiness to be sought, in keeping with the fundamentals of Man’s
Liberty against Government-over-Man, according to each Individual’s own
goals, tastes, aspirations and ideals which are themselves in an
ever-changing state of development–from childhood to life’s end.
Definition Emphasizes Self-development, Self-discipline
3. “Life” thus means infinitely more than mere continued physical
existence. “Happiness” lies in freedom of opportunity of The
Individual–chiefly Freedom from Government-over-Man–to strive to realize
to the full his own highest potential with regard to all aspects of
life. “Happiness” is not a condition but an ideal of ever-changing
aspirations, of an ever-expanding vision of self-fulfillment through
self-realization and through self-development spiritually, morally,
intellectually, in every respect. This ideal and vision are incapable of
ever being fully defined, much less completely realized. It is a
never-ending process of inner growth, not something external to be
pursued and possessed. It is comparable to the horizon–ever-widening, as
viewed from peak to higher peak of attainment with heightened
understanding. As the sages of all ages have taught, true happiness–as
distinguished from mere satisfaction of desires–is to be achieved
primarily through such self-development and growth, with each
Individual’s progress depending on his own state of being and capacity.
This can come mainly through service of lofty goals, whether subjective
and personal or objective in character, which are conducive to
broadening vision and unceasing effort toward achievement. Each
Individual’s standard of happiness to be sought for self is
fundamentally subjective–not subject to external pressures or controls
of any sort from any source, least of all by government, and not subject
to being judged by others on any comparative basis, however seemingly
eccentric or inadequate in their opinion.
The particular rights to “Life” and to “the pursuit of Happiness,”
like all of the others among Man’s God-given, unalienable rights, are
subject to the requirements of the duty factor of Individual
Liberty-Responsibility under constitutionally limited government,
including especially the observance of due respect for the equal rights
of others. This involves self-discipline under self-government’s system
of Rule-by-Law (basically the people’s fundamental law, the
Constitution). Self-discipline is the alternative to being disciplined.
Innumerable Things of Limitless Scope
4. The things embraced by these words of the Declaration of
Independence: “Life” and “the pursuit of Happiness,” are innumerable and
limitless in scope. They are as incapable of being fully listed and
bounded as are the things embraced by that basic freedom: freedom of
choice–the freedom to do or not to do–among life’s innumerable
possibilities hour by hour, day by day, life-long.
The Key: Voluntary Cooperation Based on Spiritual Unity
5. According to the American philosophy, voluntary cooperation among
Individuals and groups of Individuals is the key to expression, in the
multitudinous ways of Free Men, of the spirit of harmonious and
progressive community life in the ethical environment of a sound
society, as part of the enjoyment of the right to “Life” and to “the
pursuit of happiness.” This means, of course, so long as their aims are
not violative of the equal rights of others or of just laws expressive
of “just powers” (to quote the term of the Declaration of Independence)
designed to safeguard the equal rights of all Individuals. Such
cooperation is, in truth, an outgrowth of inner unity and harmony among
Men born of Man’s spiritual nature–of spiritual brotherhood in the light
of the common Fatherhood of God. This is a part of equal freedom for
each and every Individual in the separate enjoyment of Life and the
pursuit of Happiness, with each one responding voluntarily, from
unfettered personal choice only, in any associative or cooperative
activity socially, economically, religiously, or politically. Here
“voluntary” highlights the key element.
The Practical Application Typical of Americans
6. The American philosophy teaches that in practice this pertains,
for example, to charitable, philanthropic, educational, religious,
fraternal and other community activities–local, regional, and national.
Among such activities by Individuals, illustrations of traditional
American practices in neighborhood and community are providing help on
the local level for the needy (who are incapable of self-help) as an
expression of the benevolent spirit of charity, as well as providing aid
to Individuals and institutions in the fields of education, medicine
(health), religion and child welfare. The American scene has
traditionally been characterized by such a free, generously full,
self-fulfilling and unceasing display of this practical idealism of
voluntary cooperation for group and community welfare–on such a massive
scale within, as well as among, communities generally on a country-wide
basis–as to be a highly distinctive feature of American life which
elevates its moral tone and, when understood, causes admiration
throughout the civilized world. It constitutes, in practice, a vital
part of the American concept of Individual Liberty-Responsibility,
expressive of The Individual’s self-defined duty based on a personal
moral code founded on religious-moral considerations and also stemming
from the fundamental American idealism of Free Man. The prime motive
here is one of Man’s loftiest attainments morally and spiritually:
compassion for his fellow-man, which ennobles the concept of charity–aid
given by the Individual to others.
Coercion Excluded
7. To be spiritual and moral, this cooperation–in the enjoyment of
the right to “Life” and “the pursuit of Happiness”–must never be in any
degree involuntary. It must be wholly free from any element of
interference or coercion, direct or indirect, by government or by
others. If not voluntary, it amounts to seeking a false goal such as
“forced brotherly love”–a concept which is self-contradictory. If not
voluntary, it can have no relationship to truly moral and spiritual
values underlying the principle of Man’s concern for the well-being of
his fellow-man. The moral and the spiritual, as opposed to coercion, are
mutually exclusive. Coerced unity, forced togetherness, can only be
external and create increased conflict and separateness because true
unity, which is inner or spiritual unity, is possible only among the
free in spirit–among genuinely Free Men.
No Sacrifice of Any Right of Any Individual
8. In connection with the meaning of the right to “Life” and to “the
pursuit of Happiness,” the American philosophy defines the common good,
or the general welfare, as being fundamentally and principally the sum
of the well-being of all Individuals acting voluntarily–alone as well as
cooperatively–in the separate and full enjoyment of their equal,
unalienable rights, especially the right to freedom of choice. It cannot
be saved by any sacrifice of any of these rights of any Individual–for
example, by any subordination of any of them to any Government-over-Man
philosophy’s goals, or coercive system. Any sacrifice of any right of
any Individual is morally wrong. It is also dangerous potentially to all
rights of all Individuals and, therefore, threatens grave injury to the
general welfare, to the common good, which depends basically upon
observance of due respect for the equal rights of each and every
Individual. Thus to victimize any Individual as to any of his
rights–through either government coercion, or by pressures by other
Individuals socially, economically, or otherwise–is to victimize
potentially every Individual because this sets a precedent which is
conducive to later disregard of the rights of others, to Individual
Liberty’s peril if not grave injury.
The End Does Not Justify the Means
9. No matter how “good” the end may seem to be, there could not
possibly be any justification for the use of evil means in pursuing it.
The precedent of doing so in one instance could not but be evil and
breed evil. No action or pronouncement by government contrary to those
guiding precepts could have any validity morally or constitutionally
under the American philosophy and system of constitutionally limited
government designed primarily to make and keep secure the equal rights
of all Individuals.
What Is Not Meant
10. Among the things excluded by the word “Happiness” (of The
Individual), under the traditional American philosophy, is any element
of Government’s providing economic support, or security, for the
people–of Government’s assuming the role, the authority and
responsibility, of satisfying their material desires. Such a role for
Government would have been considered by The Founders and their fellow
Americans to be the very antithesis of, as utterly hostile to, the
American philosophy of Man-over-Government. When they expressed ideas
such as that “The Happiness of society is the first law of every
government”–as stated, for example, by James Wilson–they contemplated
primarily and mainly Government’s fulfilling its assigned role, as the
creature and instrument of the people, as defined and limited in the
Declaration of Independence: to make and keep secure the God-given,
unalienable rights of The Individual. This means, above all else,
Government’s operating strictly and invariably within the confines of
its limited, enumerated powers as prescribed by the sovereign people in
their fundamental law, the Constitution, through which they create their
tool: Government. This is designed to serve the basic goal: of
Government’s being conducted by all public officials–within the
prescribed limits of their respective spheres of constitutional
authority and responsibility–so as to ensure to the maximum the people’s
freedom to enjoy their unalienable rights, notably their right to
Liberty: The Individual’s Freedom from Government-over-Man. The word
“Happiness” and the term “pursuit of Happiness”–as used in the
Declaration of Independence and by The Founders and their fellow
Americans–exclude everything in conflict with the foregoing
considerations.
The Conclusion
11. The American philosophy teaches that the conception of how best
to enjoy the benefits of the right to “Life” and to “the pursuit of
Happiness” is a strictly personal matter for each Individual as Free
Man–free in mind and spirit as well as in body and acting consistently
with the duties of Individual Liberty-Responsibility, including chiefly
the duty of respecting the equal rights (basically the constitutional
rights) of others–to the exclusion of any coercion by government or by
others.
Principle 7 – Equal, by God’s Gift, in the Eyes of God
The Principle
1. The traditional American philosophy teaches that all men are
created equal, made equal at birth by their Creator, but equal only in
the sight of God and Law.
Basic Definition of Equality
2. This philosophy asserts that equality in the sight of God is in
the religious realm and means being equal spiritually, while equality in
the sight of Law means being entitled to equal legal justice and having
the right to be considered and treated as equal in Freedom from
Government-over-Man. Equal legal justice means equal treatment under
equal laws–that is, just laws expressive of “just powers” (to quote the
term used in the Declaration of Independence) designed to make and keep
secure the equal rights of all Individuals and, therefore, compatible
with Natural Law (God’s Law) on which Man’s God-given, unalienable
rights are based. It requires respect by government for such equal
rights of all Individuals. Also included, of course, is equality as to
The Individual’s duties underlying Individual Liberty-Responsibility,
especially the duty to respect the equal rights of others.
The Ideal of Equality in 1776 – in the Face of Inherited Slavery System
3. This word equal, according to the American philosophy as defined
in the Declaration of Independence, means equal in freedom of The
Individual. This bars slavery of Man to Man. This truly expressed the
American ideal and goal in 1776, despite the laws then making slavery
legal in America as the result of an ancient system inherited from the
Old World–fostered by the slave trade which was supported by the king of
England despite protests of the Colonies, as noted in Jefferson’s
“Rights of British America” (1774) and in his first draft of the
Declaration of Independence. At the first opportunity to act in this
regard, in adopting the Northwest Ordinance of 1787, the Congress
prohibited slavery from being practiced in the Northwest Territory. The
fact that slavery had to be faced as an existing condition in 1776, and
the difficulty and slowness of its ultimate abolition, did not impair
the spiritual integrity of the 1776 proclamation of the ideal and goal
of the American philosophy in these words of the Declaration of
Independence: “all men are created equal”–in the sight of God and Law.
By 1776, a number of slave-owning leaders–notably Washington, Jefferson,
and George Mason–were deeply concerned about the need and desirability
of abolishing slavery (through appropriate government action). It was
generally recognized that the inherited institution of slavery was
violative of the principle of Natural Rights and therefore of the
American philosophy as proclaimed in the Declaration of Independence. To
repeat, the then-existing fact of slavery in America did not lessen the
value, or impair the integrity or validity, of the Declaration’s
definition and proclamation of The American Ideal–the hope and goal of
the American philosophy–with which slavery was inconsistent. Indeed,
this fact magnified the nobility of this Ideal’s proclamation.
Equality in Freedom of Opportunity for Self-Development
4. The Declaration’s pronouncement assured a sound philosophical
basis for equality in freedom of opportunity–Freedom from
Government-over-Man–to realize to the full the Individual’s own highest
potential in all aspects of life. This involves maximum freedom of
choice. This is always subject to observance of the duties of Individual
Liberty-Responsibility under constitutionally limited government,
including the duty to respect the equal rights of others.
Equality in Freedom from Government-over-Man in the Economic Realm
5. In the economic realm also, this word “equal,” as used in the
Declaration of Independence, means only equal in freedom of opportunity.
That is, freedom from the Government-over-Man type of restrictions upon
The Individual’s opportunity to strive for material security and
advancement through his own self-reliant efforts, as he plans and
manages his own life and work and the economic security of himself and
his dependents. It means equal in freedom from those things which add up
to Government-over-Man in general.
Individual Self-reliance and Group Cooperation Constitute the Sound American Formula
6. The American philosophy makes the question of economic security
the responsibility of The Individual and of groups of Individuals.
Examples will be clarifying. First and foremost are the family and,
further, religious groups as well as fraternal groups–all acting
voluntarily. Self-reliance of The Individual is the key here, whether
acting singly or cooperatively with other Individuals.
Public “Aid” for the Genuinely Needy Must Be on Lowest Possible Governmental Level
7. Any locality’s necessity to provide public aid for the relatively
few persons who are helplessly and genuinely needy, judged by the
“means” test (to determine the need of government aid to live), must be
met on the lowest possible governmental level, under the traditional
American philosophy and system of constitutionally limited government
and decentralized power. This is according to the controlling intent of
those who framed and adopted the Constitution and each of its
amendments, under which the Federal government is prohibited from
performing this task either directly, or indirectly through financial
aid to State or local governments or to Individuals. (See also Pars.
8-10 of Principle 5 and Pars. 4-5 of Principle 11.) This is partly
because Federal aid inescapably results in time in Federal control,
either directly or indirectly–sometimes by subtle means. This
decentralized power of government to provide public aid to the genuinely
needy assures maximum safeguards against fraud, waste, political
manipulation, and other adverse results in the administration of such
activity. This decentralization saves money for the people as taxpayers
whose funds pay the bill, in last analysis, no matter which government
does the taxing for this purpose; and, at the same time, best results
are obtained for all concerned, including the needy.
Equality as to Non-infringement by Other Individuals
8. The American philosophy also teaches equality in freedom of
enjoyment of The Individual’s unalienable rights, therefore equality in
freedom from infringement of those rights by other Individuals (who
would, by any such infringement, trespass beyond the limits of their own
equal rights)–freedom in strict conformity with the Constitution, as
amended. This applies whether any would-be infringers act as separate
Individuals, or in groups, or in formal organizations such as
associations of men in the economic realm – for instance, employers’
associations, or employees’ organizations. If any such violation of any
Individual’s unalienable rights, or the supporting rights, be
perpetuated with the connivance of government–by its sin of omission or
commission, by its sanction through either threat or actual use of
force, or by enacted law–the offense is all the more anti-moral,
anti-Constitution and anti-American. No allegedly good end can justify
use of evil means such as this, according to the American philosophy’s
code of ethics and the underlying moral code.
Equality of Right to Be Let Alone
9. The ideals and principles, the spirit and lofty vision, of
traditional America give highest priority to the concept of the
inviolability of each Individual’s right to full liberty–including
complete freedom of each Individual’s right to full liberty–including
complete freedom of choice–in his own private life and in his choice of
associates in all aspects of life. This is limited only by the
requirements of the duty aspect of Individual Liberty-Responsibility:
due respect for the equal rights of others and for just laws (per Par. 2
above). This refers, for example, to laws such as criminal laws against
a conspiracy to commit murder, or a conspiracy designed to subvert all
American values and governments such as the Kremlin-controlled Communist
(“Party”) conspiracy in America–involving properly punishable guilt by
association of persons (not of ideas) for an evil and justly forbidden
purpose, the guilt being evidenced basically by the overt act of joining
the conspiracy. Also included is the most comprehensive of rights and
the right most valued by civilized men–the right of The Individual to be
let alone by government. In America, this means to be let alone in the
enjoyment of his unalienable rights, under the protection of the
safeguards provided by the Constitution. This right to be let alone
applies equally against infringement of The Individual’s privacy in this
regard by other Individuals, whether acting singly, in groups, or in
organizations. This right to be let alone is co-extensive with, and
substantially overlaps, the right to freedom of choice: the right to do
as one pleases subject only to the above-mentioned duty aspect of
Individual Liberty-Responsibility. The anti-morality of the evil precept
that the end justifies the means–that an allegedly good end justifies
resort to evil means to accomplish it–is most offensive in the eyes of
the American philosophy’s moral code stemming from the fundamental
principle of Man’s creation and endowment with rights from God. An
example is resort to this evil precept in attempted justification of
infringement of The Individual’s above mentioned right to freedom of
choice of associates in every realm of private life–the economic,
social, religious and community in general; and all the more so when any
violation of the Constitution is also involved in any such
infringement. This anti-morality is compounded in evil implication if
any government coercion is involved; which is true partly because
government coercion (always backed by force, or the threat of force), so
used, can later be used in reverse to compel disassociation–also
violative of The Individual’s freedom of choice.
Examples of What “Equality” Does Not Mean
10. To understand the meaning of the word “equal” more clearly and
precisely, mention of what it does not mean is needed. For example, it
does not mean equal opportunity, much less government-provided equal
opportunity–but means equal freedom of opportunity as a part of Freedom
from Government-over-Man. It does not mean being equal with regard to
government-provided security (even if any such phantom goal for all the
people were feasible for a long period without their abject slavery to
government under a system of prison-type security). Nor does it mean
being equal as to anything whatever to be provided by government, except
equal legal justice under equally applied laws–the above-mentioned just
laws. It certainly does not mean equality in servitude to government in
any degree, however disguised–for example as tax-slaves subjected to
the tyranny of oppressive, even confiscatory, taxes used for instance by
usurpers to buy popular support for activities in furtherance of their
usurpations in defiance of the Constitution’s limits on their powers.
More Examples
11. The word “equal” in the Declaration of Independence assuredly
does not mean being born equal in the sense of being identical–either
mentally, or physically, or in intelligence, or in capabilities, or in
character, or in virtues, or in potential in regard to accomplishments
or attainments, or in any of the various other ways in which men differ
by nature’s dispensation, from birth to death. It does not mean being
equal with regard to any supposed right to material possessions, or to
any claimed right to government-provided economic assistance, support,
or security.
Equality in Private Life Excluded
12. As a final example, the word “equal” does not mean any kind or
degree of government-provided, much less government-forced, equality in
private life, such as social equality. Such a meaning would be
flagrantly in violation of the spirit of the Declaration of Independence
as well as of the spirit and letter of the Constitution, when construed
in keeping with the original and always-controlling intent of those who
framed and adopted the initial instrument and each of its amendments.
Any idea of government-forced equality in Man’s private life, social or
otherwise–whether the forcing be done by “police state” methods or by
any other type or degree of pressure by government or by others
(threatened or applied, including “moral” pressure)–is bankrupt
spiritually and morally. It is on a par with “forced brotherly love,” a
monstrous concept which is the product of “confusing the vocabulary.” It
violates the above-discussed right to be let alone, the right to
freedom of choice, of the other Individuals involved, whose right to
this aspect of Liberty cannot justly be thus sacrificed in the name of
Equality; which would thereby be perverted into inequality as to
Liberty, in conflict with the duty aspect of Individual
Liberty-Responsibility. The power of government, or any private group,
cannot ever justly and properly be used in connection with any such
victimizing of any aspect of any Individual’s Liberty.
The Conclusion
13. In sum, the word “equal” in the Declaration of Independence
means, first, spiritual equality (equality in the sight of God) and,
second, equality in the sight of Law (basically the people’s fundamental
law, the Constitution)–primarily equality in Freedom from
Government-over-man.
Principle 6 – Decentralizd Government
The Principle
1. The traditional American philosophy teaches that decentralization
of governmental power, to the maximum practicable extent, is essential
to the security of Man’s God-given, unalienable rights.
Man’s Unalienable Rights and “States Rights” Doubly Protected
2. It asserts that these rights are most securely protected by a
federated system of government–consisting of a central government (a Republic)
and State governments (each a Republic). Under this system, the whole
quantity of governmental power is not only limited by written
Constitution, Federal and State, but also decentralized so that the vast
majority of powers are kept on the State and local levels. The correct
definition of a Republic is: a constitutionally limited government of
the representative type, created by a written Constitution–adopted by
the people and changeable (from its original meaning) by them only by
amendment–with its powers divided between three separate branches:
Executive, Legislative and Judicial. The American system is “a compound
Republic”–a federation, or combination, of central and State
Republics–under which: “The different governments will control each
other . . . ,” while within each Republic there are two safeguarding
features: (a) a division of powers, as well as (b) a system of checks
and balances between separate departments: “Hence a double security
arises to the rights of the people.” (The Federalist, number 51, by Madison.)
Greater Quantity of Power Retained by Each State
3. By far the greater quantity and variety of power was retained by
the government of each State when the United States Constitution was
framed and adopted in 1787-1788. Only a comparatively small part of each
State’s power was delegated by its people to the new central, or
Federal, government–chiefly the powers concerning “war, peace,
negotiation and foreign commerce” (per The Federalist, number 45 by
Madison). This delegated-power government–the central Republic–was
granted few and limited powers; while each State’s government is a
full-power Republic under the State Constitution, subject to its
restrictions, also to that grant, and to the few restrictions specified
expressly in the United States Constitution as applying to the
governments of the States.
“Home Rule” the Basic, Controlling Principle
4. This federated system of decentralized power is a chief
characteristic of the American governmental arrangements. This is in
keeping with the controlling intent of those who framed and adopted each
of its Amendments. The main aim was to preserve maximum “Home Rule” by
the States, to keep the greatest feasible quantity of power as close as
possible to the source–the people–where they can best watch it alertly
so as to check and prevent its abuse or misuse, as well as to prevent
its unsound, or unnecessary, expansion, to the peril or perhaps doom of
their liberties.
Economic Liberty and Decentralized Government
5. Such decentralized government is favorable, indeed essential, to
America’s traditional philosophy and system of economic liberty–the
inseparable and indispensable economic aspect of the indivisible whole
of Individual Liberty-Responsibility. This includes the system of
individual, private, competitive enterprise (called Individual
Enterprise–the term used by President Jefferson in his 1801 Annual
Message to Congress). This system features a free-market economy–free
from Government-over-Man controls, although subject to just regulation as
authorized by the Constitution’s pertinent provisions) under just laws
expressive of “just powers” (to use the term of the Declaration of
Independence) designed to protect the equal rights of all Individuals
and thus to safeguard sound competition–which gives full play to
individual initiative inspired by the incentive of economic liberty of
The Individual and is a main characteristic of the traditional American
philosophy. This right is not a goal or end, in and of itself, but a
necessary means, and it is an essential and main support of Man’s
unalienable rights. It involves freedom of choice by both
producer-seller and consumer-buyer, subject always to the potently
persuasive influence of community opinion and standards in the sound
environment of an ethical society which emphasizes the duty factor of
Individual Liberty-Responsibility, including due respect for the equal
rights of others. This means that the central government is limited
strictly to the consistent role of mere regulation (not control) to
those ends–regulation as limited by the Constitution. This excludes any
control by the central government directly or indirectly of the whole or
any part of the national economy, which includes all of the people’s
economic activities.
The free-market economy is controlled by the people as a whole
through their acting as buyers and sellers–a multitude of Individuals
generally acting individually as both buyer and seller of things or
services a number of times each day in the ordinary course of life’s
daily activities, involving transactions great or small–through their
exercise of freedom of choice daily, even hourly; for example, the
free-market economy is both a result and instrument of the exercise of
this freedom of Individuals–not a mechanistic, independently operating
“Thing” which oppressively controls human beings.
Sample Warnings by The Founders
6. The American people and their leaders in 1776-1787 were determined
that the central government should never be allowed to possess power to
act, or be permitted to act, as a “consolidated” government with
sovereign, unlimited power over all of the people and things in the
country. Vigilant friends of Individual Liberty, including for example
leaders such as Thomas Jefferson, Samuel Adams, Alexander Hamilton and
James Madison, warned repeatedly and emphatically against the danger of
ever permitting such a government to exist in America.
Samuel Adams’ Opinion
7. Samuel Adams, firebrand patriot-leader always in the lead for both
American Independence and Man’s Liberty against Government-over-Man,
expressed fear in this regard in 1789 (letter to Richard Henry Lee) in
keeping with his never varying sentiments. He said that he feared
misinterpretation of the Constitution would bring about fully
centralized (consolidated) power in the Federal government at the
expense of the States and “sink both in despotism.”
Hamilton’s Opinion
8. In the New York Ratifying Convention in 1788, Hamilton warned
sharply that the States’ powers reserved under the Constitution must be
safeguarded for the sake of Individual Liberty and that Congress would
never fail to safeguard them: “. . . unless they become madmen.”
Hamilton and Madison in “The Federalist”
9. This sound line of thought was stressed by Hamilton and Madison, in their joint report in The Federalist (for example, numbers 17 and 28 by Hamilton, and 45 and 46 by
Madison), recording the intent of the 1787 Framing Convention as
expressed in the Constitution. The foregoing sentiments of these leaders
were shared by their fellow leaders and the American people in general
of that day–as reflecting truly American principles–and by Jefferson
second to none.
Jefferson’s Opinion
10. In his First Inaugural Address as
President, Jefferson stated that the State governments are “the surest
bulwarks against anti-republican tendencies”–that is, tendencies which
conflict with the American form of government: a Republic.
He stated in a letter to Destutt de Tracy (1811): “But the true
barriers [bulwarks] of our liberty in this country are our State
governments . . .” With regard to the people’s freedom from
Government-over-Man controls by the Federal government, in keeping with
the Constitution’s limits on that government’s power, Jefferson stated
in his Annual Message to Congress, in 1801: “Agriculture, manufactures,
commerce, and navigation, the four pillars of our prosperity, are the
most thriving when left most free to individual enterprise.” In the
above-mentioned 1811 letter, Jefferson also discussed the prospective
use of the Militia of the States–all acting together–to resist the
forces of any Federal usurpers acting in violation of the Constitution
to oppress or dominate the people or government of any State.
Some Peaceable Remedies of the People Against an Offending Federal Government
11. Some of the peaceable remedies of the people of any State against
what they consider to be anti-Constitution, or otherwise offensive,
conduct by the Federal government–by any of its Branches, or by all of
them combined–as contemplated by the Convention which framed the
Constitution, were specified in The Federalist number 46 by Madison, with silent acquiescence of his co-author Hamilton, as follows:
“On the other hand, should an unwarrantable measure of the federal
government be unpopular in particular states, which would seldom fail to
be the case, or even a warrantable measure be so, which may sometimes
be the case, the means of opposition to it are powerful and at hand. The
disquietude of the people, their repugnance and perhaps refusal to
co-operate with the officers of the union, the frowns of the executive
magistracy [officials] of the state, the embarrassments created by
legislative devices, which would often be added on such occasions, would
oppose in any state difficulties not to be despised; would form in a
large state very serious impediments, and where the sentiments of
several adjoining states happened to be in union, would present
obstructions which the federal government would hardly be willing to
encounter.”
The most extremely “unwarrantable measure” is an unconstitutional
measure. Madison here expressed the understanding also of those who
framed the Constitution and of their fellow leaders in the State
Ratifying Conventions as well as of the people in general–all extremely
jealous of their hard-won liberties and determined to act vigorously
against any danger to them from the greatly feared, central government
if it should ever threaten to over-step the limits imposed on its powers
under the constitution, as amended. Protests by State legislatures
against what they would consider to be abuses of power or usurpations,
potential or actual, by the central government were of course included
as a main element in what Madison referred to her as “legislative
devices . . . impediments . . . obstructions.” Actual examples occurring
afterward are the Kentucky and Virginia Resolutions of 1798 and the Hartford Convention Resolutions of 1815 (discussed in Principle 3, Pars. 5-6).
Some additional remedies of the people, of a peaceable nature, are
political action–use of the ballot in elections–and amendment of the
Constitution by the people (Art. V); while impeachment by Congress of any officials guilty of acting as defaulting public trustees is provided for (Art. I, Sec. 2,3).
State’s Self-defense by Force, in Last Resort, per “The Federalist”
12. With regard to use by the States of force–use of their Militia
forces (all able-bodied males capable of bearing arms)–in self-defense
against any Federal usurpers seeking to oppress or dominate one or more
States by force in violation of the Constitution’s limits on Federal
power, Hamilton and Madison discussed at length and in detail in The Federalist (numbers 28 by Hamilton and 46 by
Madison) the assumption and expectation of The Framers that all States
would marshall their forces and act jointly to crush the usurpers’
forces. This understanding of The Framers was shared by the members of
the State Ratifying Conventions and the leaders and people in general of
that day–all fearless foes of any and all enemies of Free Man in
America. They believed that all true Americans must be ready to fight
and die for Liberty, especially against tyrannical Federal officials
who, as usurpers, violate not only the Constitution but also their oath
of office: to support the Constitution only. It was also
contemplated that any non-military force used by the Federal usurpers
would be countered by the States’ use of their own non-military forces:
Sheriff’s posses (posses comitatus) and any civilian police forces. (See also Par. 12 of Principle 5.)
The Civil over The Military
13. The traditional American philosophy requires, as a fundamental of
the system of checks and balances, that The Civil must always be in
complete control of The Military. The Founders and their fellow
Americans were painfully aware of the lesson of history that large
standing armies are, in peacetime, potentially dangerous to the people’s
liberties. In 1776, the Virginia Declaration of Rights,
for example, made this clear in these words: “. . . that standing
armies in time of peace should be avoided as dangerous to liberty; and
that in all cases the military should be under strict subordination to,
and governed by, the civil power.” Another, related element in the
system of checks and balances is the requirement of the Constitution (Article VI) that all Federal officials–both civil and military–take an oath to support the Constitution [only];
with the result that all military officers, thus controlled
fundamentally and supremely by the Constitution, must be obedient to the
civil authority–chief of all the President–but only as to orders which
are not violative of the Constitution. The Military are, therefore,
obligated by the Constitution not only to refuse to obey any orders of
Federal usurpers–automatically made by the Constitution itself null and
void from the start–but to support the Constitution only, at all times
and under all circumstances, as the sovereign people’s fundamental law.
State officials, civil and military, are likewise so required to take an
oath to support the Constitution of the United States–meaning, in part,
to resist Federal usurpers by all necessary means: by force in last
resort.
The Conclusion
14. The truly American formula, in accordance with the traditional
philosophy, for sound and enduring self-government by means of
constitutionally limited government with adequate protection assured for
Individual Liberty, is this: Limited and Decentralized for Liberty.
Principle 5 – Limited Government
The Principle
1. The traditional American philosophy teaches that government must
be limited in power if Individual Liberty is to be safeguarded, if each
Individual’s God-given, unalienable rights are to be made and kept
enduringly secure.
“Just Powers” Defined
2. This philosophy asserts that the self-governing people allow any
government they may organize to possess, by grant from them, only the
limited and few powers with which the people think the particular
government may sensibly be entrusted in order to serve their purposes
without endangering their rights–their liberties or freedoms. These
powers constitute the “just powers” of government, as the Declaration of
Independence phrases it. This is in keeping with the primary purpose
for which the people organize governments: to make and keep these
unalienable rights secure and most beneficial to themselves and to
Posterity–time without end.
“Limited” – a Key Word
3. “Limited government” is a key term in the American philosophy. Its
great significance is indicated by describing the purpose of limiting
government’s power in these words: Limited for Liberty. This summarizes
what is meant by the statement in the Declaration of Independence about
governments being limited in power “to secure these rights”–to make and
keep them ever secure. “Limited” means limited by a written Constitution
adopted by the sovereign people as their basic law–never changing in
its meaning, as originally intended by The Framers and Adopters, except
subject to change by the people only by amendments at any time and to
any extent they may see fit. All governments in America are thus limited
by written Constitutions–by the United States Constitution as the
“supreme Law of the Land” and, as to each State government, by that
States’ Constitution. (Note again Par. 4 of Principle 3, regarding the
first eight, or Bill of Rights, amendments being intended to apply
against the Federal government only.)
Limited Powers, Duties, Responsibilities and Limited Threat to Liberty
4. The few and limited powers of the United States government are
enumerated and defined in the people’s fundamental law–the Constitution,
as amended. This is the basis of Rule-by-Law (basically the people’s
fundamental law, the Constitution) in contrast to Rule-by-Man. The
limited quantity of its powers means it is limited in potential threat
to the people’s liberties. These “just powers,” being few and limited,
automatically define the limits of the duties which the people assign to
this government. It can have no duties, no responsibilities, other than
those consistent with the limits of the powers granted to it by the
people in the Constitution, as amended, It is equally as violative of
the Constitution for government to assume duties–to pretend to have
responsibilities–as it is to grasp powers, beyond these prescribed
limits.
Division of Powers and Checks and Balances
5. As a further safeguard for the people’s rights, The Framers and
Ratifiers of the Constitution provided for division of powers not only
between the Federal and State governments but also within the Federal
government between its three, separate Branches and, further, specified
various checks and balances among these Branches, to help prevent either
usurpation of power (grasping unauthorized power) or misuse of the
limited quantity of power granted to it by the people: as explained, for
instance, by Madison in The Federalist number 51. Each of the Branches
was designed to help restrain the other Branches from any violation of
the Constitution. The admonition on this topic expressed in Washington’s
Farewell Address reflected the conviction of all of The Founders.
“It is important, likewise, that the habits of thinking in a free
Country should inspire caution in those entrusted with its
administration, to confine themselves within their respective
Constitutional spheres; avoiding in the exercise of the Powers of one
department to encroach upon another. The spirit of encroachment tends to
consolidate the powers of all the departments in one, and thus to
create whatever the form of government, a real despotism. The necessity
of reciprocal checks in the exercise of political power; by dividing and
distributing it into different depositories, and constituting each the
Guardian of the Public Weal against invasions by the others, has been
evinced by experiments ancient and modern; some of them in our country
and under our own eyes. To preserve them must be as necessary as to
institute them.”–George Washington (Farewell Address; Emphasis added)
The Compound Republic
6. The limitation of government’s power, by a written Constitution
adopted by the people (by the electorate), is the main distinguishing
characteristic of a Republic. The correct definition of a Republic is: a
constitutionally limited government of the representative type, created
by a written Constitution–adopted by the people and changeable (from
its original meaning) by them only by its amendment–with its powers
divided between three separate Branches: Executive, Legislative and
Judicial. Each American government, Federal and State, is a Republic;
and such a form of government is expressly guaranteed to each State by
the United States Constitution. (Article IV, Section 4.) This makes the
American system a combination, or federation , of Republics–a compound
Republic as noted in The Federalist number 51 by Madison. Although the
term “Federal Republic” has sometimes been used to refer both to the
central (Federal) government and to the federated system of
Republics–including both central government and State governments (all
Republics)–it will facilitate clear thinking if this term “Federal
Republic” is applied only to the central government while using the
phrase “federated system of Republics” or “federation of Republics” to
designate the combination, or confederation, of all of these Republics.
Clarity of understanding will be best assured by referring to the
central government as the central Republic.
The electorate adopt a Constitution as their basic law by utilizing a
Constitutional Convention to frame it for their final approval, or
ratification, as was done successfully for the first time in history by
the people of Massachusetts with regard to its Constitution of 1780; it
was so framed by a convention specially chosen by the people for this
sole purpose and then submitted to the people for approval. Final
adoption, or ratification, may also be effected in behalf of the people
by a specially chosen convention for this sole purpose; and later
amendments may be so approved for the people or through the regular
legislative body–the alternatives specified in the United States
Constitution. This Constitution was framed by the Federal
(Constitutional) Convention in 1787 and then adopted in 1787-1788 by
State Ratifying Conventions especially chosen by the people for this
sole purpose; which is the complete and perfect method of
Constitution-making. A Constitutional Convention–one chosen by the
people for the sole purpose of framing or ratifying a Constitution–is
one of America’s greatest contributions, to the mechanics of
self-government through constitutionally limited government.
Federal Delegated-Power, and State Full-Power, Republics
7. The Federal government is a delegated-power Republic which
possesses only the comparatively few and limited powers granted to it by
the people as enumerated in the United States Constitution, as
amended–chiefly the powers concerned with “war, peace, negotiation, and
foreign commerce” (quoting The Federalist, number 45 by Madison. It is
in sharpest contrast that each State government is a full-power Republic
which possesses the vast and varied powers needed to administer
intra-State affairs–“all the objects which, in the ordinary course of
affairs, concern the lives, liberties, and properties of the people, and
the internal order, improvement, and prosperity of the State” (again
quoting number 45). The full-power Republic of each State is subject to
the State Constitution, as well as to the united States Constitution as
the “supreme Law of the Land.” Neither the Federal, nor any State,
government therefore possesses legal sovereignty–the unlimited power of
sovereignty–while the people’s political sovereignty is limited in favor
of preserving inviolate the God-given, unalienable rights of each
Individual. (See Par. 3, Principle 4.)
The “General Welfare” in Relation to the Constitution
8. The Preamble of the United States Constitution specifies “the
general Welfare” merely as one of the listed goals to be served by the
Federal government in the exercise of the limited powers delegated to
it, as enumerated in the body of that instrument. This mention of “the
general Welfare” in the Preamble was intended, therefore, to serve in
effect as a limit on the use of those delegated powers. The Preamble
does not constitute a grant of any power whatever to the government. The
only other mention of the words “general welfare” in the Constitution
is in the Taxing Clause (Article I, Section 8) which authorizes Congress
to collect taxes “. . . to pay the Debts and provide for the common
Defense and general Welfare of the United States . . .” Here, too, the
words “general Welfare” were designed to serve as a limitation in
effect–as a limit on the power granted under that clause. This excludes
any power to tax and spend for all purposes which would not qualify as
being for the “general Welfare of the United States” as a whole–for
instance, it is excluded if for the benefit merely of a locality or some
Individuals in the United States. The clause does not empower Congress
to spend tax monies for any and every purpose it might select merely on
the pretense, or even in the belief, that it is for the “general
welfare.” (Discussed also in Pars. 4 and 5 of Principle 11.) Congress
possesses no “general legislative authority,” as Hamilton stated in The
Federalist number 83.
Hamilton’s Opinion
9. All of those who framed and ratified the Constitution were in
agreement on this point of the limited and limiting meaning of the words
“general Welfare” in the Taxing Clause. As Secretary of the Treasury,
Hamilton contended for the first time in 1791 (“Opinion as to the
Constitutionality of the Bank of the United States”) in favor of a
broader interpretation of this clause than he had formerly espoused and
broader than that which Madison – with Hamilton’s silent
acquiescence–had presented in 1788 in The Federalist (especially number
41) as reflecting the controlling intent of the Framing Convention,
which Madison and Jefferson consistently supported. Hamilton did not
claim, however, that this clause gives to the Federal government any
power, through taxing-spending, so as in effect to control directly or
indirectly anything or anybody, or any activities of the people or of
the State governments. Despite his assertion that this clause gives
Congress a separate and substantive spending power, Hamilton cautioned
expressly (Report on “Manufactures,” 1791) that it only authorizes
taxing and spending within the limits of what would serve the “general
welfare” and does not imply a power to do whatever else should appear to
Congress conducive to the “general welfare”–that it does “not carry a
power to do any other thing not authorized in the Constitution, either
expressly or by fair implication.”
The Supreme Court’s 1936 Decision Ascertaining and Defining the Original, Controlling Intent
10. As the Supreme Court decided (1936 Carter case) in ascertaining
and defining the original, controlling intent of the Constitution as
proved by all pertinent records and confirming its prior decisions over
the generations since the adoption of the Constitution, the contentions
advanced from time to time that “Congress, entirely apart from those
powers delegated by the Constitution, may enact laws to promote the
general welfare, have never been accepted but always definitely rejected
by this court.” It also decided that the Framing Convention “made no
grant of authority to Congress to legislate substantively for the
general welfare . . . [citing 1936 Butler case] . . . and no such
authority exists, save as the general welfare may be promoted by the
exercise of the powers which are granted.” The American people have
never amended the Constitution so as to change the limited and limiting
meaning of the words “general Welfare” in the Taxing Clause, as thus
originally intended by The Framers and Adopters in 1787-1788.
The Founders’ Warnings
11. As Jefferson warned many times in his writings, public and
private–for instance in the Kentucky Resolution–in keeping with the
traditional American philosophy, strict enforcement of the
Constitution’s limits on the Federal government’s power is essential for
the protection of the people’s liberties. This point was stressed at
great length in The Federalist (notably numbers 17, 28, 33 and 78 by
Hamilton and 44 and 46 by Madison) in reporting and explaining the
intent of the Framing Convention expressed in the Constitution–as was
understood and accepted by the State Ratifying Conventions. Hamilton’s
repeated warnings against permitting public servants to flout the
people’s mandate as to the limits on government’s power, as specified in
their basic laws (Constitutions) creating their governments, were in
keeping with his words on one occasion in relation to the New York State
Constitution. He stated (“Letters of Phocion,” 1784) that any such
defiance, by public servants, of the Constitution would be “a
treasonable usurpation upon the power and majesty of the people . . .”
Washington’s Farewell Address expressed the conviction of The Founders
of the Republic and their fellow leaders, in keeping with history’s
lesson, when he warned that usurpation “is the customary weapon by which
free governments are destroyed.”
Resistance to Usurpers, as Tyrants, Is Obedience to God
12. It is a traditional American motto that: “Rebellion to tyrants is
obedience to God.” This motto was suggested by Benjamin Franklin in
mid-1776 in the Congress as being an appropriate one for the seal of the
United States; and it was so truly expressive of traditional American
thinking that Jefferson adopted it for use on his personal seal.
A major part of the American philosophy underlying the resistance to
the tyranny of king and parliament prior to the Declaration of
Independence, and in support of that Declaration in 1776, was as
follows. Public officials who exceed the limits of the powers delegated
to them by the people under their fundamental law and thus violate, or
endanger, the people’s God-given, unalienable rights thereby and to this
extent make of themselves defaulting trustees, usurpers, oppressors and
tyrants. They thereby act outside of this supreme law, which defines
these limits and the scope of their authority and office, and therefore
act without authority from the people. By thus seceding and violating
the restrictions of this law, they act outside of Law: lawlessly, as
“out-laws.” As Samuel Adams stated: “Let us remember, that ‘if we suffer
tamely a lawless attack upon our liberty, we encourage it, and involve
others [Posterity] in our doom’” (Emphasis added.) They thereby, in
practice, replace Rule-by-Law with Rule-by-Man. These defaulting
trustees–thus acting lawlessly–thereby free the people from any duty of
obedience; because legally and morally, under Rule-by-Law, obedience by
the self-governing people is required only to Law and not to law-defying
public servants.
The reasoning supporting the above-quoted motto’s concept of moral
duty is this: Man, being given by his Creator unalienable rights which
are accompanied by corresponding duties, has the moral duty–duty to
God–to safeguard these rights for the benefit of self and others,
including Posterity. Man is therefore obligated to oppose all violators
of these rights; and such failure betrays Man’s duty as the temporary
trustee of Posterity’s just heritage. This is in keeping with the
philosophy of the Declaration of Independence as reiterated in part, for
example, in 1788 in the Virginia Ratifying Convention’s proposals for
amendments to the Constitution including a Bill of Rights stating in
part as follows:
“. . . that the doctrine of non-resistance against arbitrary
power and oppression is absurd slavish, and destructive of the good and
happiness of mankind.”
Applied to the United States Constitution, which Federal and State
officials are sworn to support, this means that–in resisting Federal
officials who, as usurpers, defy the limits on their powers imposed by
the “supreme Law of the Land”–the people and governments of the States
are opposing Rule-by-Man and defending Rule-by-Law (basically the
people’s fundamental law: the Constitution). They are thus defending the
Constitution against its violators: the Federal usurpers; and they are
acting in defense of the people’s God-given, unalienable rights and the
States’ reserved powers. The American philosophy and system of
constitutionally limited government contemplates that the people of the
several States–acting through their State governments–will, in last
resort, use force to oppose any force employed by the Federal usurpers,
that they will use military force (Militia of the States) to oppose any
military force used by such usurpers; as Hamilton and Madison explained
in detail in The Federalist, numbers 28 and 46.
The Conclusion
13. The American philosophy reflects the knowledge that the history
of Individual Liberty is the history of the effective limitation of
government’s power, which is expressed in the traditional principle
summarized in the phrase: Limited for Liberty.
Principle 4 – Man Organizes Governments to be His Tools
The Principle
1. The traditional American philosophy teaches that government is
merely the creature and a tool, or instrument, of the sovereign people.
Government’s Primary Function
2. The people create their governments primarily to serve one supreme
purpose: to “secure” the safety and enjoyment of their God-given,
unalienable rights. To make and keep them secure is government’s primary
function and chief reason for existence, according to the philosophy
proclaimed in the Declaration of Independence.
Government a Tool
3. This makes clear the correct role of government in relation to the
people, as viewed by the American philosophy. It is merely their tool,
like any other tool such as saw, or a plow, or a steam engine, created
by them to serve its assigned and limited purpose. As the people’s tool,
or instrument, any government could never soundly be said to possess
sovereign power–that is, unlimited, or total, power over all things and
all persons. Under the American philosophy, no legal, meaning
governmental, sovereignty exists anywhere; while any political
sovereignty is possessed by the people alone and even they are limited
by the obligation to keep inviolate the God-given, unalienable rights of
every Individual. Government may possess and its officials may
exercise, as the people’s servants and trustees, only such limited part
of the people’s power as they see fit from time to time to delegate to
it through their fundamental law: the Constitution, as amended by them;
and this applies to all governments and Constitutions, Federal and
State.
Government Lacks “Just Power” to Violate Rights
4. Therein lies the significance of the limitation by the people of
government’s role and power, under the American philosophy. The fact
that government cannot have any “just” power or authority–as meant by
the term “just powers” in the Declaration of Independence–to violate any
unalienable right of The Individual follows from the fact that no
Individual can have any right, power or authority to violate any other
Individual’s unalienable rights. Because it is created by the people (a
group of Individuals) primarily for the purpose of making secure all
rights of all Individuals, this tool of the people, government, could
not conceivably derive from them any power or authority, morally or
constitutionally, to do the opposite by infringing any such right. Since
no Individual possesses, or could grant, any such power or authority,
the many Individuals composing the people of a country are similarly
lacking; many times zero equals zero. No vote of the people, by however
great a majority–even all of the people but one Individual, opposed to
that lone Individual–could give to any government any such authority or
power. (This is subject, of course, to the point previously discussed in
Paragraph 9 of Principle 3, regarding just punishment of offenders
against just laws, or against the rights of other Individuals.)
Government Cannot Delegate Any Power to Violate Man’s Rights 5. By the
same token, it is impossible for the people’s tool, government, to
possess any authority from the people–any “just power” (to use the term
of the Declaration of Independence)–to delegate to others any power
which it does not and could not possess under the traditional American
philosophy. As such a tool, government could not possibly possess, could
not be given, any power to authorize any person, group or organization
to do that which it is itself powerless to do. This precludes, for
example, government’s authorizing or empowering any person, group, or
organization to violate any Individual’s unalienable rights–including
the right to “Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness”–or any of the
supporting rights, such as the right to property and to freedom of
association.
No Coercion of Man as to His Labor
6. Under the American philosophy, these supporting rights include,
for example, The Individual’s right to use all of his faculties,
talents, abilities and energies–basically his own labor–as, when and
where he sees fit without any restraint by government or by others. This
is subject, of course, to his duly respecting the equal rights of other
Individuals (in part as discussed regarding Equality in Pars. 8-9 of
Principle 7) and just laws expressive of the above-mentioned “just
powers” of government designed to help safeguard the equal rights of all
Individuals. This means, for example, the enjoyment of this right
without any such restraint upon his right to freedom of association, to
freedom of choice with regard to joining, or not joining, any
organization–for instance, an organization of his fellow employers or an
organization of his fellow workers. Violation of this right involves
necessarily violation of his unalienable rights to “Life, Liberty and
the pursuit of Happiness” as well as of the supporting rights–notably
the right to property (money or any other type), including acquiring,
possessing and using it. Such violation results in any case of coercion
of The Individual to join, or not to join, such an organization. This is
true whether perpetuated by government directly, or by it indirectly
through others acting with its sanction–for instance, by any group or
organization of other Individuals who exert pressures of any kind or
degree to induce, or impel, him so to join, or to refrain from joining.
As Man’s tool, government not only can have no just power so to
perpetuate any such violation but is affirmatively obligated, under just
laws, not only not to tolerate but actively to prevent such violation
by others–always strictly in keeping with its limited powers and related
responsibilities as prescribed in the applicable Constitution (as
amended), Federal or State, as the case may be. To repeat, any
Individual’s right to freedom of association (freedom of choice of
associates) is always subject to the equal rights of others – including
their right to similar freedom of choice of associates. This right’s
enjoyment always involves the essential factor of mutual consent, free
from any element of coercion.
Sovereign Citizen over Public Servant
7. All public officials are subordinate as public servants to all
citizens. Under the American philosophy of Man-over-Government, the
American heritage assumes that the most modestly circumstanced
Individuals among the sovereign people rank higher than any public
officials, even those serving as the highest ranking of public servants.
It is a case of The Sovereign over servant–each Individual in this
regard representing in a sense the sovereign people as the creator of
their tool, or instrument: government.
Betrayal of the American Heritage
8. It was the firm conviction of those who founded America–notably
the leaders of the period 1776-1787 and their fellow Americans in
general–that to forget, neglect , or defy this great American principle
is to betray the American heritage of Individual Liberty–Man’s Freedom
from Government-over-Man–and to contribute in practice to its erosion,
or subversion. Sins of omission in this connection are as heinous as
sons of commission. Any public servants who ignore this truth are guilty
of desecration of the spirit of traditional America and the higher the
offender’s rank, the worse the offense morally. Any Individual who
condones such an offense against this heritage is similarly blameworthy.
The Conclusion
9. Each Individual, among the sovereign and self-governing people,
embodies a part of the supreme sovereignty of the people in relation to
their creature and tool, or instrument, government, and to its officials
as public servants–wholly subservient to the people as their superiors,
their masters.
