• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Dealing With the World Today

A personal blog on the world today and dealing with it as a Christian.

Principle 2 – Fear of Government Over Man

March 8, 2020 by Jim Vaughan Leave a Comment

The Principle

1. A main principle of the traditional American philosophy is expressed in the phrase: fear of Government-over-Man.

Cause of Fear

2. This fear is due to the ever-present, never-changing weaknesses of
human nature in government which are conducive to “love of power and
proneness to abuse it,” as Washington’s Farewell Address warned. This
means public officials’ human weaknesses, especially as aggravated by
the corresponding weaknesses among the self-governing people themselves.
It is a truism that government’s power needs only to exist to be
feared–to be dominant, over the fear-ridden, without ever needing to be
exercised aggressively.

Man–Good and Evil, Mixed

3. This philosophy asserts that human nature is a mixture of good and
evil, of strength and weakness, and is not perfectible during life on
earth. There is “a portion of virtue and honor among Mankind” and the
better side of Man, the Individual, can be strengthened and made more
dependable through spiritual growth. The resulting moral development is
conducive to sound conduct, in keeping with conscience in the light of a
personal moral code based upon religious-moral considerations. Yet
history teaches that the previously mentioned weaknesses of human nature
provide just cause for never-ceasing fear of Government-over-Man.

Government Like a Fire

4. Americans of the period 1776-1787 firmly believed in the soundness
of the accepted maxim that “government is like a fire: a dangerous
servant and a fearful master;” that, to be useful, it must be strictly
controlled for safety against its getting out of hand and doing great
harm. Through the generations, the people have considered that this
maxim expresses one of history’s most profoundly important lessons for
Free Man. This maxim is based upon the knowledge that, in last analysis,
government is force and must be feared and controlled accordingly. The
great fear in 1787-1788 of the new, central government under the
proposed Constitution was evidenced by the fact that the State Ratifying
Conventions proposed scores of amendments, designed chiefly to keep
under more rigid control what they considered to be this potential
monster of power so dangerous to their liberties: the central, or
Federal, government.

The Views of Jefferson and Madison and the Kentucky and Virginia Resolutions

5. This fear was of abuse by government of power granted to it by the
people, as well as of usurpation by it of power denied or prohibited to
it by them, through the Constitution, to the injury if not doom of
their liberties–of the God-given, unalienable rights of The Individual.
Jefferson merely voiced the lesson of history–well known to, and
accepted by, his fellow Americans–when he stated, in the “Diffusion of
Knowledge” Bill in 1779, in the Virginia legislature:

“. . . experience hath shewn, that even under the best forms [of
government], those entrusted with power have, in time, and by slow
operations, perverted it into tyranny . . .”

Jefferson also expressed this traditional, American viewpoint in his
famous writing known as the Kentucky Resolutions, as adopted in 1798 by
the Kentucky legislature, in these words in part:

“. . . it would be a dangerous delusion were a confidence in the
men of our choice to silence our fears for the safety of our rights:
that confidence is everywhere the parent of despotism: free government
is founded in jealousy and not in confidence; it is jealousy and not
confidence which prescribes limited Constitutions to bind down those
whom we are obliged to trust with power: that our Constitution has
accordingly fixed the limits to which and no further our confidence may
go; . . . In questions of power then let no more be heard of confidence
in man, but bind him down from mischief by the chains of the
Constitution.”

These Kentucky Resolutions are closely akin to the contemporaneous
Virginia Resolutions of 1798 adopted soon afterward by the Virginia
legislature–written mainly by Madison who was, as usual, in close touch
with Jefferson in this period. Both sets of resolutions were protests
against what were considered and denounced as abuses and usurpations of
power by the Federal government–chiefly through the Alien and Sedition
Laws adopted by Congress in 1798. Such protests by a State legislature
were in keeping with the remedies available to the States in such a
situation – remedies contemplated by The Framers as being within the
constitutional system–as discussed, for example, by Madison in 1788 in
The Federalist number 46. The Sedition Act was designed to restrict
freedom of speech and of the Press so as to stifle criticism of Federal
officials and therefore grossly violated the Constitution; and it was
opposed, for example, by John Marshall, as a member of Congress, and by
Alexander Hamilton–the latter stating: “Let us not establish a tyranny.”
(These laws soon disappeared from the statute books, due to their
widespread unpopularity which the above-mentioned 1798 resolutions had
helped initially to foster.)

Precedents for Other States’ Protests Such As The Hartford Convention Resolutions

6. These 1798 protests by the Kentucky and Virginia legislatures were
not the first such development in the life of the Republic. A
predecessor resolution of protest, for example, had been adopted by the
Virginia legislature in 1790: the “Protest and Remonstrance” against the
assumption by the Federal government of the war-incurred debts of the
States, as being unconstitutional. This protest set a precedent for the
above-mentioned 1798 resolutions. They, in turn, set precedents for
similar resolutions of protest adopted by various States–in New England,
the North, the Mid-west as well as in the South–during the following
decades when they considered themselves to be victimized, potentially or
actually, by either abuses or usurpations of power by the Federal
government; such developments being the subject of comment, for example,
by former President John Quincy Adams in his celebrated “Jubilee”
address of April 30, 1839. (Some of these later resolutions even relied
on the Virginia Resolutions of 1798 as a precedent.) An example is the
set of resolutions adopted in 1815, during the war with England, by the
Hartford Convention–representing Massachusetts, Connecticut, Rhode
Island, Vermont, and New Hampshire–protesting against what were
considered to be Federal usurpations, potential or actual, regarding use
of the States’ Militia in war operations and other national defense
matters.

The View of Patrick Henry

7. In the Virginia Ratifying Convention in 1788, Patrick Henry
protested with vehemence against the proposed new Constitution’s lack of
adequate limits on the central government’s power, lack of sufficient
safeguards against governmental abuses due to human weaknesses among its
officials, saying:

“Show me that age and country where the rights and liberties of
the people were placed on the sole chance of their rulers being good
men, without a consequent loss of liberty! I say that the loss of that
dearest privilege has ever followed, with absolute certainty, every such
mad attempt.”

The American People’s View Also Expressed in the Pittsfield Petition of 1776

8. These quoted sentiments were accepted as maxims by American
leaders in general and by the American people as a whole in that
generation of Free Men–free in spirit and willing to fight and die for
their Freedom from Government-over-Man. This acceptance is illustrated
by the below-quoted words of the Pittsfield, Massachusetts, town-meeting
petition of a decade earlier, in May, 1776. It was penned by the
Reverend Thomas Allen, ardent friend of American Independence and of
Man’s Liberty against Government-over-Man. It stated why Massachusetts
needed a new, basic law of the people, a Constitution to be adopted by
the people only, in part as follows:

“That knowing the strong bias of human nature to tyranny and
despotism, we have nothing else in view but to provide for posterity
against the wanton exercise of power, which cannot otherwise be done
than by the formation of a fundamental constitution.”

This petition reflected the sentiments of the frontier, “backwoods”
people of Berkshire County, led by this patriot as head of “The
Berkshire Constitutionalists,” over a decade before the 1787 Federal
Convention framed the United States Constitution. These were truly the
sentiments of the American people at large. They are in harmony with the
later phrasing of this idea as follows in The Federalist (number 55, by
Madison):

“As there is a degree of depravity in mankind which requires a
certain degree of circumspection and distrust: So there are other
qualities in human nature, which justify a certain portion of esteem and
confidence.”

Never-changing Weaknesses of Human Nature Create Never-changing Need for Safeguards

9. The never-changing need for, and value of, constitutional
safeguards against abuse, or usurpation, of power by public servants–as
contemplated, and as provided for, by The Framers and Adopters of the
Constitution in 1787-1788 and by those who proposed, framed and adopted
the first ten Amendments (including the Bill of Rights made applicable
against the Federal, or central, government only)–are due to the
never-changing weaknesses of human nature in government and among the
self-governing people. These weaknesses never change; therefore the need
for these safeguards can never change.

The Conclusion

10. Fear of Government-over-Man was the dominant fear in that day of
uncompromisingly individualistic Americans–Free Men, ever jealous of the
safety of Individual Liberty, of the security of their God-given,
unalienable rights against violation by government.

Related

Filed Under: Historical, The 12 Principles

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Primary Sidebar

Post Archive

Site Index

  • About Me
  • Important Historical Documents
  • Recommended Links for Topic Research
  • Recommended Links on Religion
  • The 12 Basic Principles
  • The 28 Great Ideas

Post Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Genesis Sample on Genesis Framework · Powered by WordPress.com. · Log in