The Principle
1. The traditional American philosophy teaches that tyranny through
taxation is one of the most dangerous and oppressive aspects of
Government-over-Man and must be guarded against and opposed accordingly,
for the protection of Man’s God-given, unalienable rights.
The Precedent of 1776
2. Tyrannous abuse of the taxing power was a principal provocation of
the American Revolution in 1776 and, according to this philosophy, will
always be considered and treated as just cause for prompt, effective,
remedial action by every generation of Americans worthy of the American
heritage of Individual Liberty–the heritage of Free Man determined to
preserve his Freedom from Government-over-Man. This can be done mainly
through preserving inviolate the supporting system of constitutionally
limited government, designed to restrict government’s activities and
therefore its cost and taxes.
Limited Taxing Power
3. The traditional American philosophy of constitutionally limited
government–Limited for Liberty–is hostile to any concept which would
permit any unlimited power of taxation to exist to the peril of Man’s
unalienable rights. Potential danger, not merely present danger, is the
crux of the matter and the reason for constitutional safeguards, which
are designed to provide protection in the worst imaginable situations.
This philosophy prescribes various limitations upon the taxing power of
the Federal government, as expressed in the Constitution. For example,
Article 1, Section 8, of the Constitution authorizes Congress to make
only specified levies–within the bounds of certain specific limits as to
uses of tax monies: “to pay the Debts and provide for the common
Defence and general Welfare of the United States.” It also authorizes
taxes only to raise revenue to pay for the government’s authorized
activities, within the bounds of its limited powers and limited duties
under the Constitution, as amended–for use directly and openly to
accomplish the objects committed to its care and the trusts for which it
is made responsible by the people under this basic law. This is
according to the controlling intent of those who framed and ratified the
Constitution in 1787-1788, and likewise as to each amendment.
Examples of What Is Not Authorized
4. A few examples of what is not authorized by the Constitution in
this regard, therefore as impliedly prohibited, will be clarifying. In
general, the power of taxation may not be used by the Federal government
as a means of bringing about indirectly and subtly any governmental
change, or any social or other type of reform, or to achieve indirectly
in effect Federal control of anything or anybody, or to accomplish any
other result whatever, which the people have not authorized by the
Constitution to be accomplished directly and openly. Nor may the power
of taxation be used in furtherance of any abuse of the limited powers
granted to the Federal government, or in furtherance of activities due
to usurpation of any power withheld from it, or denied or prohibited to
it, expressly or impliedly, by the people through the Constitution, as
amended.
It is especially noteworthy that Hamilton, as Secretary of the
Treasury, in urging for the first time in 1791 that the Taxing Clause
granted to the Federal government a separate and substantive power for
the application of money, “within the limits of what would serve the
general welfare,” conceded that such power would “not carry a power to
do any other thing not authorized in the Constitution, either expressly
or by fair implication.” (See Pars. 8-10 of Principle 5.)
Some specific examples are as follows. The power of taxation may not
be used so as to prevent criticism of the Federal government by the
Press; which would be exercising power over a field of activity withheld
from this government by the original Constitution and expressly
prohibited by the First Amendment. Nor may taxes be used to obtain funds
to subsidize, and in effect to control, any field of activity denied to
this government (excluded from its enumerated powers) and reserved to
the States by the Constitution–so as in effect to “buy” submission to
Federal usurpers: such as agriculture. Hamilton made it expressly clear,
in The Federalist number 17, that this is a field of activity over
which the Federal government had been given no power–a field over which
it could never properly be given any power to control. Also, taxes may
not be used to stifle, undermine, or destroy any part of the traditional
American system’s economic aspect of Liberty such as Individual
Enterprise (individual, private, competitive, enterprise).
Equally repugnant and prohibited are taxes designed to put into
effect the anti-private-property idea, or plan, of “leveling” of
ownership of property (money or any other type) by attempting to make
all people more “equal” as to property, or as to income, by taking from
some to give to others–as a means of achieving social reform or any
other purpose not directly and openly authorized by the people in the
Constitution. For example, in 1768 a Resolution of the Massachusetts
House of Representatives (drafted by James Otis, Samuel Adams et al)
denounced such leveling as being “despotic and . . . unconstitutional.”
Two decades later The Federalist (number 10, by Madison) condemned it as
“improper” and “wicked.” Jefferson decried leveling as being unjust and
violative of “the first principle of association”–meaning a people’s
associating for purposes of self-government.
The Examples Continued
5. Congress is not authorized to tax and spend as it pleases, for any
and every purpose which it may choose to say, or actually thinks, will
serve the “general welfare.” Those who framed and ratified the
Constitution in 1787-1788 intended the Taxing Clause’s words: “general
Welfare of the United States,” to serve as a limitation on the taxing
power. These words were designed to restrict taxing and spending to
constitutionally authorized objectives, meaning in part only those which
would serve the welfare of the United States as a whole and not merely
of a locality, not of individual citizens. Congress does not possess
unlimited, sovereign power to tax the people. (See Pars. 8-10 of
Principle 5.) It does not even possess “general legislative authority,
as Hamilton stated in The Federalist number 83.
Congress has, of course, been granted no power to exceed its
constitutional authority or responsibilities by being benevolent, by
making donations, of money or property at home or abroad at the expense
of the American people’s income, or other money or property. According
to the controlling intent of those who framed and ratified the
Constitution, the only words in the Taxing Clause which could possibly
be said to sanction any donation to any foreign government, or people,
are the words “national defense”–meaning direct and actual military
defense of the American homeland. Any and all foreign donations by the
Federal government are, therefore, clearly prohibited by inescapable
implication unless, and except to the limited extent that any such
donation in actuality helps directly and substantially, on a realistic
military basis, to “provide for the common Defence . . . of the United
States”–of the States composing the Union.
These few illustrations exemplify prohibited misuse of the limited
taxing power as granted by the people to the Federal government under
the Constitution, as amended.
Peril to Liberty–Multiplied
6. The traditional American philosophy recognizes that an unlimited
power to tax involves the power to destroy–a truth long known. This
becomes all the more evilly significant if, when and to the extent that
the Federal government becomes guilty of wholesale usurpation of power
to expand its activities, at home and abroad, in defiance of the limits
on its power imposed by the sovereign people through the Constitution.
The evil significance involved is greatly augmented when–in furtherance
of such wholesale usurpation–any such official culprits: Federal
usurpers, employ oppressive taxation so as in effect to finance their
political schemes to keep themselves in power, in control of the
government, by using vast sums of public monies to subsidize–in truth to
bribe, corrupt and seduce–immense segments of the electorate through
distribution of individual money “benefits”, to win their votes. This
aim and process are furthered by building up a vast governmental
bureaucracy which helps to serve this objective but has no sensible
relation to sound governmental operations serving constitutionally
authorized purposes. Then, indeed, are Individual Liberty and sound
self-government in America–also the integrity and safety of the Republic
itself–placed in effect on the auction block. This potentially
disastrous condition, of danger compounded, becomes almost unlimited in
degree of peril for Free Man in America, for American Posterity, when
this combination of usurpation and tax tyranny is employed–by such
usurpers and their collaborators in all walks of life–to supplant the
traditional American system of Man-over-Government with the system of
Government-over-Man. The foregoing precepts reflect some aspects of The
Founders’ thinking in this connection. (Note especially the Jefferson
quotation on page xx, ante, about taxing–spending–electing.) Any
accomplishment of the prohibited objectives by gradual and deceptive
steps–rather than directly and openly–highlights the importance of
keeping ever in mind a maxim of which the sense was well-known to them
and is expressable in verse form as follows:
Great Oaks and Great Tyrannies
Just as surely as “great oaks from little acorns grow,”
So do greatest tyrannies have smallest beginnings;
Yet the mind, uninstructed by knowledge or reason,
Cannot sense either oak or tyranny in the seed.
No Unlimited Income-Tax Power Under the Principle of Limited Government
7. The foregoing holds good even though the traditional American
philosophy and system contemplate the Federal government’s possessing,
by grant of the people under the Constitution, “an unqualified power of
taxation in the ordinary modes,” as stated in The Federalist (number 31,
by Alexander Hamilton)–for instance, a consumption tax on sales of
goods. Such a tax cannot become dangerous to the people’s liberties
because it contains an automatic check on abuse by way of such taxation;
if the amount of the tax offends them, they can simply refuse to buy
the goods and thereby make the tax a failure, leading to its repeal.
Even “an unqualified power of taxation” in some mode which was not
ordinary in the days of The Founders and was not provided for by them in
the Constitution–for instance, a graduated, “escalating” income tax,
especially without expressly specifying a maximum rate or
“ceiling”–would nevertheless have been considered by them to be
impliedly limited in effect because subject to the following factors.
First, the principles proclaimed in the Declaration of
Independence–notably that governments are granted only “just powers,”
meaning limited powers, in order to make and keep secure the people’s
unalienable rights–forbid the existence in America of any system of
government or governmental practices which could, in effect and in the
unlimited discretion of public servants, impose tax-slavery upon the
people through permitting these public, servants in peacetime to
confiscate most, or all, of the income of the people to be spent as
these public servants may please. This assuredly would have been
considered by The Founders to be the very definition of tax-tyranny,
which was one of the chief causes of the Revolution in 1776. Second, the
system intended to be created by The Framers and Adopters of the
Constitution–with only the few, limited powers enumerated being granted
to the Federal government (for example, per The Federalist number 45 by
Madison with Hamilton’s silent concurrence)–likewise bars tax-tyranny
because Congress is authorized to tax and spend only within the scope of
its power-limits and its commensurately limited responsibilities; which
must always be construed in keeping with that original, controlling
intent of The Framers and Adopters, subject only to amendment by the
people of the Constitution. Congress may not tax and spend in support of
activities in furtherance of abuse of any granted power or in support
of usurpation of power not granted.
The Founders would assuredly have stressed these implied limits upon
any power to tax incomes of the people–if granted by and constitutional
amendment–in the absence of an express, specific and clear mandate from
the people to the contrary stated in any such amendment, for instance if
it should expressly authorize confiscatory taxes for war needs. Just as
they certainly would have condemned any generation of Americans as
being unfaithful to the American heritage of Man-over-Government, as
being defaulting trustees of Posterity’s just heritage, because of any
submission to oppressive taxation amounting to tax-tyranny. This applies
equally to taxation of accumulated wealth (savings), or property, by
way of inheritance, or estate. taxes (death taxes), which are equally
subject to the above-mentioned principles and implied limits.
The basic American principles previously discussed: “Limited and
Decentralized for Liberty” (per Principles 5 and 6) would therefore,
have been declared by The Founders to be respected and protected in
effect and impliedly by pertinent, controlling limitations despite any
income-tax, or any death-tax, provision in any amendment to the
Constitution not expressly fixing a maximum rate or “ceiling.” They
would have agreed that the above-mentioned implied limits would
nevertheless be applicable, though not made express, so as to bar
unlimited taxing-power opening the door to tax-tyranny, tax-slavery.
Benjamin Franklin’s Example
8. When government takes a part of an Individual’s earned income,
this is the equivalent of government’s commandeering, or confiscating,
for its own purposes a corresponding portion of his working time; he is
deprived of the benefit, of the fruit, of such work and time. A
taxpayer’s time is employed in the service, or support, of government to
the extent that be must devote it to earning the money required to pay
the taxes imposed by government. Benjamin Franklin suggested a specific
standard or rule by which to judge the character of taxation, presumably
in peacetime (not in a national crisis of war), as to whether or not it
is oppressive and beyond which the burden of taxation would, in his
opinion, presumably have been considered oppressive, if not tyrannous.
It was stated by him in a 1758 writing:
“It would be thought a hard Government that should tax its People
one tenth Part of their Time, to be employed in its Service.” (Emphasis
his.)
(Maximum income-tax rate was only seven per cent under [the] 1913 law–the first under the Sixteenth Amendment.)
Under the American philosophy and system of constitutionally limited
government, there is and always must be some limit, express or implied,
as a standard beyond which the people may properly, indeed should,
consider peacetime taxation to amount to impermissible confiscation and
therefore oppression and tax-tyranny. Otherwise a mockery is made of the
fundamental American principle of limited government. One general test
which is unchallengeable, under a system of constitutionally limited
government, is this: any and every aspect of taxation which is designed
to provide financial support for any governmental activity which
involves abuse of granted power, or usurpation of ungranted power,
merits condemnation as tax-tyranny.
The Conclusion
9. It is a cardinal principle of the traditional American philosophy
that taxes must be limited to safeguard Individual Liberty–to make and
keep secure Man’s unalienable rights and Posterity’s just heritage of
Liberty: Freedom from Government-over-Man.
Leave a Reply