• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Dealing With the World Today

A personal blog on the world today and dealing with it as a Christian.

Principle 5 – Limited Government

March 8, 2020 by Jim Vaughan Leave a Comment

The Principle

1. The traditional American philosophy teaches that government must
be limited in power if Individual Liberty is to be safeguarded, if each
Individual’s God-given, unalienable rights are to be made and kept
enduringly secure.

“Just Powers” Defined

2. This philosophy asserts that the self-governing people allow any
government they may organize to possess, by grant from them, only the
limited and few powers with which the people think the particular
government may sensibly be entrusted in order to serve their purposes
without endangering their rights–their liberties or freedoms. These
powers constitute the “just powers” of government, as the Declaration of
Independence phrases it. This is in keeping with the primary purpose
for which the people organize governments: to make and keep these
unalienable rights secure and most beneficial to themselves and to
Posterity–time without end.

“Limited” – a Key Word

3. “Limited government” is a key term in the American philosophy. Its
great significance is indicated by describing the purpose of limiting
government’s power in these words: Limited for Liberty. This summarizes
what is meant by the statement in the Declaration of Independence about
governments being limited in power “to secure these rights”–to make and
keep them ever secure. “Limited” means limited by a written Constitution
adopted by the sovereign people as their basic law–never changing in
its meaning, as originally intended by The Framers and Adopters, except
subject to change by the people only by amendments at any time and to
any extent they may see fit. All governments in America are thus limited
by written Constitutions–by the United States Constitution as the
“supreme Law of the Land” and, as to each State government, by that
States’ Constitution. (Note again Par. 4 of Principle 3, regarding the
first eight, or Bill of Rights, amendments being intended to apply
against the Federal government only.)

Limited Powers, Duties, Responsibilities and Limited Threat to Liberty

4. The few and limited powers of the United States government are
enumerated and defined in the people’s fundamental law–the Constitution,
as amended. This is the basis of Rule-by-Law (basically the people’s
fundamental law, the Constitution) in contrast to Rule-by-Man. The
limited quantity of its powers means it is limited in potential threat
to the people’s liberties. These “just powers,” being few and limited,
automatically define the limits of the duties which the people assign to
this government. It can have no duties, no responsibilities, other than
those consistent with the limits of the powers granted to it by the
people in the Constitution, as amended, It is equally as violative of
the Constitution for government to assume duties–to pretend to have
responsibilities–as it is to grasp powers, beyond these prescribed
limits.

Division of Powers and Checks and Balances

5. As a further safeguard for the people’s rights, The Framers and
Ratifiers of the Constitution provided for division of powers not only
between the Federal and State governments but also within the Federal
government between its three, separate Branches and, further, specified
various checks and balances among these Branches, to help prevent either
usurpation of power (grasping unauthorized power) or misuse of the
limited quantity of power granted to it by the people: as explained, for
instance, by Madison in The Federalist number 51. Each of the Branches
was designed to help restrain the other Branches from any violation of
the Constitution. The admonition on this topic expressed in Washington’s
Farewell Address reflected the conviction of all of The Founders.

“It is important, likewise, that the habits of thinking in a free
Country should inspire caution in those entrusted with its
administration, to confine themselves within their respective
Constitutional spheres; avoiding in the exercise of the Powers of one
department to encroach upon another. The spirit of encroachment tends to
consolidate the powers of all the departments in one, and thus to
create whatever the form of government, a real despotism. The necessity
of reciprocal checks in the exercise of political power; by dividing and
distributing it into different depositories, and constituting each the
Guardian of the Public Weal against invasions by the others, has been
evinced by experiments ancient and modern; some of them in our country
and under our own eyes. To preserve them must be as necessary as to
institute them.”–George Washington (Farewell Address; Emphasis added)

The Compound Republic

6. The limitation of government’s power, by a written Constitution
adopted by the people (by the electorate), is the main distinguishing
characteristic of a Republic. The correct definition of a Republic is: a
constitutionally limited government of the representative type, created
by a written Constitution–adopted by the people and changeable (from
its original meaning) by them only by its amendment–with its powers
divided between three separate Branches: Executive, Legislative and
Judicial. Each American government, Federal and State, is a Republic;
and such a form of government is expressly guaranteed to each State by
the United States Constitution. (Article IV, Section 4.) This makes the
American system a combination, or federation , of Republics–a compound
Republic as noted in The Federalist number 51 by Madison. Although the
term “Federal Republic” has sometimes been used to refer both to the
central (Federal) government and to the federated system of
Republics–including both central government and State governments (all
Republics)–it will facilitate clear thinking if this term “Federal
Republic” is applied only to the central government while using the
phrase “federated system of Republics” or “federation of Republics” to
designate the combination, or confederation, of all of these Republics.
Clarity of understanding will be best assured by referring to the
central government as the central Republic.

The electorate adopt a Constitution as their basic law by utilizing a
Constitutional Convention to frame it for their final approval, or
ratification, as was done successfully for the first time in history by
the people of Massachusetts with regard to its Constitution of 1780; it
was so framed by a convention specially chosen by the people for this
sole purpose and then submitted to the people for approval. Final
adoption, or ratification, may also be effected in behalf of the people
by a specially chosen convention for this sole purpose; and later
amendments may be so approved for the people or through the regular
legislative body–the alternatives specified in the United States
Constitution. This Constitution was framed by the Federal
(Constitutional) Convention in 1787 and then adopted in 1787-1788 by
State Ratifying Conventions especially chosen by the people for this
sole purpose; which is the complete and perfect method of
Constitution-making. A Constitutional Convention–one chosen by the
people for the sole purpose of framing or ratifying a Constitution–is
one of America’s greatest contributions, to the mechanics of
self-government through constitutionally limited government.

Federal Delegated-Power, and State Full-Power, Republics

7. The Federal government is a delegated-power Republic which
possesses only the comparatively few and limited powers granted to it by
the people as enumerated in the United States Constitution, as
amended–chiefly the powers concerned with “war, peace, negotiation, and
foreign commerce” (quoting The Federalist, number 45 by Madison. It is
in sharpest contrast that each State government is a full-power Republic
which possesses the vast and varied powers needed to administer
intra-State affairs–“all the objects which, in the ordinary course of
affairs, concern the lives, liberties, and properties of the people, and
the internal order, improvement, and prosperity of the State” (again
quoting number 45). The full-power Republic of each State is subject to
the State Constitution, as well as to the united States Constitution as
the “supreme Law of the Land.” Neither the Federal, nor any State,
government therefore possesses legal sovereignty–the unlimited power of
sovereignty–while the people’s political sovereignty is limited in favor
of preserving inviolate the God-given, unalienable rights of each
Individual. (See Par. 3, Principle 4.)

The “General Welfare” in Relation to the Constitution

8. The Preamble of the United States Constitution specifies “the
general Welfare” merely as one of the listed goals to be served by the
Federal government in the exercise of the limited powers delegated to
it, as enumerated in the body of that instrument. This mention of “the
general Welfare” in the Preamble was intended, therefore, to serve in
effect as a limit on the use of those delegated powers. The Preamble
does not constitute a grant of any power whatever to the government. The
only other mention of the words “general welfare” in the Constitution
is in the Taxing Clause (Article I, Section 8) which authorizes Congress
to collect taxes “. . . to pay the Debts and provide for the common
Defense and general Welfare of the United States . . .” Here, too, the
words “general Welfare” were designed to serve as a limitation in
effect–as a limit on the power granted under that clause. This excludes
any power to tax and spend for all purposes which would not qualify as
being for the “general Welfare of the United States” as a whole–for
instance, it is excluded if for the benefit merely of a locality or some
Individuals in the United States. The clause does not empower Congress
to spend tax monies for any and every purpose it might select merely on
the pretense, or even in the belief, that it is for the “general
welfare.” (Discussed also in Pars. 4 and 5 of Principle 11.) Congress
possesses no “general legislative authority,” as Hamilton stated in The
Federalist number 83.

Hamilton’s Opinion

9. All of those who framed and ratified the Constitution were in
agreement on this point of the limited and limiting meaning of the words
“general Welfare” in the Taxing Clause. As Secretary of the Treasury,
Hamilton contended for the first time in 1791 (“Opinion as to the
Constitutionality of the Bank of the United States”) in favor of a
broader interpretation of this clause than he had formerly espoused and
broader than that which Madison – with Hamilton’s silent
acquiescence–had presented in 1788 in The Federalist (especially number
41) as reflecting the controlling intent of the Framing Convention,
which Madison and Jefferson consistently supported. Hamilton did not
claim, however, that this clause gives to the Federal government any
power, through taxing-spending, so as in effect to control directly or
indirectly anything or anybody, or any activities of the people or of
the State governments. Despite his assertion that this clause gives
Congress a separate and substantive spending power, Hamilton cautioned
expressly (Report on “Manufactures,” 1791) that it only authorizes
taxing and spending within the limits of what would serve the “general
welfare” and does not imply a power to do whatever else should appear to
Congress conducive to the “general welfare”–that it does “not carry a
power to do any other thing not authorized in the Constitution, either
expressly or by fair implication.”

The Supreme Court’s 1936 Decision Ascertaining and Defining the Original, Controlling Intent

10. As the Supreme Court decided (1936 Carter case) in ascertaining
and defining the original, controlling intent of the Constitution as
proved by all pertinent records and confirming its prior decisions over
the generations since the adoption of the Constitution, the contentions
advanced from time to time that “Congress, entirely apart from those
powers delegated by the Constitution, may enact laws to promote the
general welfare, have never been accepted but always definitely rejected
by this court.” It also decided that the Framing Convention “made no
grant of authority to Congress to legislate substantively for the
general welfare . . . [citing 1936 Butler case] . . . and no such
authority exists, save as the general welfare may be promoted by the
exercise of the powers which are granted.” The American people have
never amended the Constitution so as to change the limited and limiting
meaning of the words “general Welfare” in the Taxing Clause, as thus
originally intended by The Framers and Adopters in 1787-1788.

The Founders’ Warnings

11. As Jefferson warned many times in his writings, public and
private–for instance in the Kentucky Resolution–in keeping with the
traditional American philosophy, strict enforcement of the
Constitution’s limits on the Federal government’s power is essential for
the protection of the people’s liberties. This point was stressed at
great length in The Federalist (notably numbers 17, 28, 33 and 78 by
Hamilton and 44 and 46 by Madison) in reporting and explaining the
intent of the Framing Convention expressed in the Constitution–as was
understood and accepted by the State Ratifying Conventions. Hamilton’s
repeated warnings against permitting public servants to flout the
people’s mandate as to the limits on government’s power, as specified in
their basic laws (Constitutions) creating their governments, were in
keeping with his words on one occasion in relation to the New York State
Constitution. He stated (“Letters of Phocion,” 1784) that any such
defiance, by public servants, of the Constitution would be “a
treasonable usurpation upon the power and majesty of the people . . .”
Washington’s Farewell Address expressed the conviction of The Founders
of the Republic and their fellow leaders, in keeping with history’s
lesson, when he warned that usurpation “is the customary weapon by which
free governments are destroyed.”

Resistance to Usurpers, as Tyrants, Is Obedience to God

12. It is a traditional American motto that: “Rebellion to tyrants is
obedience to God.” This motto was suggested by Benjamin Franklin in
mid-1776 in the Congress as being an appropriate one for the seal of the
United States; and it was so truly expressive of traditional American
thinking that Jefferson adopted it for use on his personal seal.

A major part of the American philosophy underlying the resistance to
the tyranny of king and parliament prior to the Declaration of
Independence, and in support of that Declaration in 1776, was as
follows. Public officials who exceed the limits of the powers delegated
to them by the people under their fundamental law and thus violate, or
endanger, the people’s God-given, unalienable rights thereby and to this
extent make of themselves defaulting trustees, usurpers, oppressors and
tyrants. They thereby act outside of this supreme law, which defines
these limits and the scope of their authority and office, and therefore
act without authority from the people. By thus seceding and violating
the restrictions of this law, they act outside of Law: lawlessly, as
“out-laws.” As Samuel Adams stated: “Let us remember, that ‘if we suffer
tamely a lawless attack upon our liberty, we encourage it, and involve
others [Posterity] in our doom’” (Emphasis added.) They thereby, in
practice, replace Rule-by-Law with Rule-by-Man. These defaulting
trustees–thus acting lawlessly–thereby free the people from any duty of
obedience; because legally and morally, under Rule-by-Law, obedience by
the self-governing people is required only to Law and not to law-defying
public servants.

The reasoning supporting the above-quoted motto’s concept of moral
duty is this: Man, being given by his Creator unalienable rights which
are accompanied by corresponding duties, has the moral duty–duty to
God–to safeguard these rights for the benefit of self and others,
including Posterity. Man is therefore obligated to oppose all violators
of these rights; and such failure betrays Man’s duty as the temporary
trustee of Posterity’s just heritage. This is in keeping with the
philosophy of the Declaration of Independence as reiterated in part, for
example, in 1788 in the Virginia Ratifying Convention’s proposals for
amendments to the Constitution including a Bill of Rights stating in
part as follows:

“. . . that the doctrine of non-resistance against arbitrary
power and oppression is absurd slavish, and destructive of the good and
happiness of mankind.”

Applied to the United States Constitution, which Federal and State
officials are sworn to support, this means that–in resisting Federal
officials who, as usurpers, defy the limits on their powers imposed by
the “supreme Law of the Land”–the people and governments of the States
are opposing Rule-by-Man and defending Rule-by-Law (basically the
people’s fundamental law: the Constitution). They are thus defending the
Constitution against its violators: the Federal usurpers; and they are
acting in defense of the people’s God-given, unalienable rights and the
States’ reserved powers. The American philosophy and system of
constitutionally limited government contemplates that the people of the
several States–acting through their State governments–will, in last
resort, use force to oppose any force employed by the Federal usurpers,
that they will use military force (Militia of the States) to oppose any
military force used by such usurpers; as Hamilton and Madison explained
in detail in The Federalist, numbers 28 and 46.

The Conclusion

13. The American philosophy reflects the knowledge that the history
of Individual Liberty is the history of the effective limitation of
government’s power, which is expressed in the traditional principle
summarized in the phrase: Limited for Liberty.

Related

Filed Under: Historical, The 12 Principles

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Primary Sidebar

Post Archive

Site Index

  • About Me
  • Important Historical Documents
  • Recommended Links for Topic Research
  • Recommended Links on Religion
  • The 12 Basic Principles
  • The 28 Great Ideas

Post Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Genesis Sample on Genesis Framework · Powered by WordPress.com. · Log in