The Principle
1. The traditional American philosophy teaches that Man, The
Individual, is endowed at birth with rights which are unalienable
because given by his Creator.
The Only Moral Basis
2. This governmental philosophy is uniquely American. The concept of
Man’s rights being unalienable is based solely upon the belief in their
Divine origin. Lacking this belief, there is no moral basis for any
claim that they are unalienable or for any claim to the great benefits
flowing from this concept. God-given rights are sometimes called Natural
Rights–those possessed by Man under the Laws of Nature, meaning under
the laws of God’s creation and therefore by gift of God. Man has no
power to alienate–to dispose of, by surrender, barter or gift–his
God-given rights, according to the American philosophy. This is the
meaning of “unalienable.”
One underlying consideration is that for every such right there is a
correlative, inseparable duty–for every aspect of freedom there is a
corresponding responsibility; so that it is always Right-Duty and
Freedom-Responsibility, or Liberty-Responsibility. There is a duty, or
responsibility, to God as the giver of these unalienable rights: a moral
duty–to keep secure and use soundly these gifts, with due respect for
the equal rights of others and for the right of Posterity to their just
heritage of liberty. Since this moral duty cannot be surrendered,
bartered, given away, abandoned, delegated or otherwise alienated, so is
the inseparable right likewise unalienable. This concept of rights
being unalienable is thus dependent upon belief in God as the giver.
This indicates the basis and the soundness of Jefferson’s statement
(1796 letter to John Adams): “If ever the morals of a people could be
made the basis of their own government it is our case . . .”
Right, Reason, and Capacity to Be Self-governing
3. For the security and enjoyment by Man of his Divinely created
rights, it follows implicitly that Man is endowed by his Creator not
only with the right to be self-governing but also with the capacity to
reason and, therefore, with the capacity to be self-governing. This is
implicit in the philosophy proclaimed in the Declaration of
Independence. Otherwise, Man’s unalienable rights would be of little or
no use or benefit to him. Faith in Man–in his capacity to be
self-governing–is thus related to faith in God as his Creator, as the
giver of these unalienable rights and this capacity.
Rights–as Prohibitions Against Government
4. Certain specific rights of The Individual are protected in the
original Constitution but this is by way of statements “in reverse”–by
way of express prohibitions against government. The word “right” does
not appear in the original instrument. This is because it was designed
to express the grant by the people of specific, limited powers to the
central government–created by them through this basic law–as well as
certain specific limitations on its powers, and on the preexisting
powers of the State governments, expressed as prohibitions of things
forbidden. Every provision in it pertains to power.
The Constitution’s first eight (Bill of Rights) amendments list
certain rights of The Individual and prohibit the doing of certain
things by the central, or Federal, government which, if done, would
violate these rights. These amendments were intended by their Framers
and Adopters merely to make express a few of the already-existing,
implied prohibitions against the Federal government only–supplementing
the prohibitions previously specified expressly in the original
Constitution and supplementing and confirming its general, over-all,
implied, prohibition as to all things concerning which it withheld power
from this government. Merely confirming expressly some of the
already-existing, implied prohibitions, these amendments did not create
any new ones. They are, therefore, more properly referred to as a
partial list of limitations–or a partial Bill of Prohibitions–as was
indicated by Hamilton in The Federalist number 84. This hinges upon the
uniquely American concepts stated in the Declaration of Independence:
that Men, created of God, in turn create their governments and grant to
them only “just” (limited) powers–primarily to make and keep secure
their God-given, unalienable rights including, in part, the right to
Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. As Hamilton stated, under
the American philosophy and system of constitutionally limited
government, “the people surrender nothing;” instead, they merely
delegate to government–to public servants as public trustees–limited
powers and therefore, he added, “they have no need of particular
reservations” (in a Bill of Rights). This is the basic reason why the
Framing Convention omitted from the Constitution anything in the nature
of a separate Bill of Rights, as being unnecessary.
An Endless List of Rights
5. To attempt to name all of these rights–starting with “Life,
Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness” mentioned in the Declaration of
Independence–would be to start an endless list which would add up to the
whole of Man’s Freedom (Freedom from Government-over-Man). They would
add up to the entirety of Individual Liberty (Liberty against
Government-over-Man). Innumerable rights of The Individual are embraced
in the Ninth Amendment, which states: “The enumeration in the
Constitution of certain rights shall not be construed to deny or
disparage others retained by the people.” (Here “Constitution” includes
the amendments.) Some idea of how vast the list would be is indicated by
just one general freedom which leads into almost all of Free Man’s
activities of daily living throughout life: freedom of choice. This term
stands for the right to do–and equally not to do–this or that, as
conscience, whim or judgement, taste or desire, of The Individual may
prompt from moment to moment, day by day, for as long as life lasts; but
always, of course, with due regard for the equal rights of others and
for the just laws expressive of the above-mentioned “just powers” of
government designed to help safeguard the equal rights of all
Individuals. Spelled out in detail, this single freedom–freedom of
choice–is almost all-embracing.
Right To Be Let Alone
6. In one sense, such freedom to choose involves Man’s right to be
let alone, which is possessed by The Individual in keeping with the
Declaration and Constitution as against government: in enjoyment of his
unalienable rights, while respecting the equal rights of others and just
laws (as defined in Paragraph 5 above). This right to be let alone is
the most comprehensive of rights and the right of most prized by
civilized men. This right is, of course, also possessed as against all
other Individuals, all obligated to act strictly within the limits of
their own equal rights. Consequently any infringement of any
Individual’s rights is precluded.
Rights Inviolable by Government or by Others
7. Neither government nor any Individuals–acting singly, or in
groups, or in organizations–could possibly possess any “just power” (to
use again the significant term of the Declaration) to violate any
Individual’s God-given, unalienable rights or the supporting rights. No
government can abolish or destroy–nor can it rightfully, or
constitutionally, violate–Man’s God-given rights. Government cannot
justly interfere with Man’s deserved enjoyment of any of these rights.
No public official, nor all such officials combined, could possibly have
any such power morally. Government can, to be sure, unjustly and
unconstitutionally interfere by force with the deserved enjoyment of
Man’s unalienable rights. It is, however, completely powerless to
abolish or destroy them. It is in defense of these rights of all
Individuals, in last analysis, that the self-governing people–acting in
accordance with, and in support of, the Constitution–oppose any and all
violators, whether public officials or usurpers, or others (par. 9
below).
Each Individual Consents to Some Limitations
8. In creating governments as their tools, or instruments, and
equally in continuing to maintain them–for the purpose primarily of
making and keeping their unalienable rights–all Individuals composing
the self-governing people impliedly and in effect consent to some degree
of limitation of their freedom to exercise some of their rights. This
does not involve the surrender, or the alienation, of any of these
rights but only the partial, conditional and limited relinquishment of
freedom to exercise a few of them and solely for the purpose of insuring
the greater security and enjoyment of all of them; and, moreover, such
relinquishment is always upon condition that public officials, as public
servants and trustees, faithfully use the limited powers delegated to
government strictly in keeping with their prescribed limits and with
this limited purpose at all times. It was in this sense that George
Washington, as President of the Framing Convention in September, 1787,
wrote to the Congress of the Confederation–in transmitting to it, for
consideration, the draft of the proposed Constitution: “. . .
Individuals entering into society, must give up a share of liberty to
preserve the rest.” Here he meant merely conditional relinquishment of
liberty of action in the exercise of certain aspects of unalienable
rights–not the surrender of any unalienable rights, which would be
impossible because a nullity, a void act.
An Offender’s Just Punishment
9. Whenever Man violates either the equal rights of others or the
above-mentioned just laws, he thereby forfeits his immunity in this
regard; by his misconduct, he destroys the moral and legal basis for his
immunity and opens the door to just reprisal against himself, by
government. This means that any person, as such offender, may justly be
punished by the people’s proper instrumentality–the government,
including the courts–under a sound system of equal justice under equal
laws; that is, under Rule-by-Law (basically the people’s fundamental
law, the Constitution). Such punishment is justified morally because of
the duty of all Individuals–in keeping with Individual
Liberty-Responsibility–to cooperate, through their instrumentality,
government, for the mutual protection of the unalienable rights of all
Individuals. The offender is also justly answerable to the aggrieved
Individual, acting properly through duly-established machinery of
government, including courts, designed for the protection of the equal
rights of all Individuals.
It is the offender’s breach of the duty aspect of Individual
Liberty-Responsibility which makes just, proper and necessary
government’s punitive action and deprives him of any moral basis for
protest. By such breach he forfeits his moral claim to the inviolability
of his rights and makes himself vulnerable to reprisal by the people,
through government, in defense of their own unalienable rights. By this
lack of self-discipline required by that duty, he invites and makes
necessary his being disciplined by government.
The Conclusion
10. Man’s unalienable rights are sacred for the same reason that they
are unalienable–because of their Divine origin, according to the
traditional American philosophy.
Leave a Reply