• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Dealing With the World Today

A personal blog on the world today and dealing with it as a Christian.

Principle 6 – Decentralizd Government

March 8, 2020 by Jim Vaughan Leave a Comment

The Principle

1. The traditional American philosophy teaches that decentralization
of governmental power, to the maximum practicable extent, is essential
to the security of Man’s God-given, unalienable rights.

Man’s Unalienable Rights and “States Rights” Doubly Protected

2. It asserts that these rights are most securely protected by a
federated system of government–consisting of a central government (a Republic)
and State governments (each a Republic). Under this system, the whole
quantity of governmental power is not only limited by written
Constitution, Federal and State, but also decentralized so that the vast
majority of powers are kept on the State and local levels. The correct
definition of a Republic is: a constitutionally limited government of
the representative type, created by a written Constitution–adopted by
the people and changeable (from its original meaning) by them only by
amendment–with its powers divided between three separate branches:
Executive, Legislative and Judicial. The American system is “a compound
Republic”–a federation, or combination, of central and State
Republics–under which: “The different governments will control each
other . . . ,” while within each Republic there are two safeguarding
features: (a) a division of powers, as well as (b) a system of checks
and balances between separate departments: “Hence a double security
arises to the rights of the people.” (The Federalist, number 51, by Madison.)

Greater Quantity of Power Retained by Each State

3. By far the greater quantity and variety of power was retained by
the government of each State when the United States Constitution was
framed and adopted in 1787-1788. Only a comparatively small part of each
State’s power was delegated by its people to the new central, or
Federal, government–chiefly the powers concerning “war, peace,
negotiation and foreign commerce” (per The Federalist, number 45 by
Madison). This delegated-power government–the central Republic–was
granted few and limited powers; while each State’s government is a
full-power Republic under the State Constitution, subject to its
restrictions, also to that grant, and to the few restrictions specified
expressly in the United States Constitution as applying to the
governments of the States.

“Home Rule” the Basic, Controlling Principle

4. This federated system of decentralized power is a chief
characteristic of the American governmental arrangements. This is in
keeping with the controlling intent of those who framed and adopted each
of its Amendments. The main aim was to preserve maximum “Home Rule” by
the States, to keep the greatest feasible quantity of power as close as
possible to the source–the people–where they can best watch it alertly
so as to check and prevent its abuse or misuse, as well as to prevent
its unsound, or unnecessary, expansion, to the peril or perhaps doom of
their liberties.

Economic Liberty and Decentralized Government

5. Such decentralized government is favorable, indeed essential, to
America’s traditional philosophy and system of economic liberty–the
inseparable and indispensable economic aspect of the indivisible whole
of Individual Liberty-Responsibility. This includes the system of
individual, private, competitive enterprise (called Individual
Enterprise–the term used by President Jefferson in his 1801 Annual
Message to Congress). This system features a free-market economy–free
from Government-over-Man controls, although subject to just regulation as
authorized by the Constitution’s pertinent provisions) under just laws
expressive of “just powers” (to use the term of the Declaration of
Independence) designed to protect the equal rights of all Individuals
and thus to safeguard sound competition–which gives full play to
individual initiative inspired by the incentive of economic liberty of
The Individual and is a main characteristic of the traditional American
philosophy. This right is not a goal or end, in and of itself, but a
necessary means, and it is an essential and main support of Man’s
unalienable rights. It involves freedom of choice by both
producer-seller and consumer-buyer, subject always to the potently
persuasive influence of community opinion and standards in the sound
environment of an ethical society which emphasizes the duty factor of
Individual Liberty-Responsibility, including due respect for the equal
rights of others. This means that the central government is limited
strictly to the consistent role of mere regulation (not control) to
those ends–regulation as limited by the Constitution. This excludes any
control by the central government directly or indirectly of the whole or
any part of the national economy, which includes all of the people’s
economic activities.

The free-market economy is controlled by the people as a whole
through their acting as buyers and sellers–a multitude of Individuals
generally acting individually as both buyer and seller of things or
services a number of times each day in the ordinary course of life’s
daily activities, involving transactions great or small–through their
exercise of freedom of choice daily, even hourly; for example, the
free-market economy is both a result and instrument of the exercise of
this freedom of Individuals–not a mechanistic, independently operating
“Thing” which oppressively controls human beings.

Sample Warnings by The Founders

6. The American people and their leaders in 1776-1787 were determined
that the central government should never be allowed to possess power to
act, or be permitted to act, as a “consolidated” government with
sovereign, unlimited power over all of the people and things in the
country. Vigilant friends of Individual Liberty, including for example
leaders such as Thomas Jefferson, Samuel Adams, Alexander Hamilton and
James Madison, warned repeatedly and emphatically against the danger of
ever permitting such a government to exist in America.

Samuel Adams’ Opinion

7. Samuel Adams, firebrand patriot-leader always in the lead for both
American Independence and Man’s Liberty against Government-over-Man,
expressed fear in this regard in 1789 (letter to Richard Henry Lee) in
keeping with his never varying sentiments. He said that he feared
misinterpretation of the Constitution would bring about fully
centralized (consolidated) power in the Federal government at the
expense of the States and “sink both in despotism.”

Hamilton’s Opinion

8. In the New York Ratifying Convention in 1788, Hamilton warned
sharply that the States’ powers reserved under the Constitution must be
safeguarded for the sake of Individual Liberty and that Congress would
never fail to safeguard them: “. . . unless they become madmen.”

Hamilton and Madison in “The Federalist”

9. This sound line of thought was stressed by Hamilton and Madison, in their joint report in The Federalist (for example, numbers 17 and 28 by Hamilton, and 45 and 46 by
Madison), recording the intent of the 1787 Framing Convention as
expressed in the Constitution. The foregoing sentiments of these leaders
were shared by their fellow leaders and the American people in general
of that day–as reflecting truly American principles–and by Jefferson
second to none.

Jefferson’s Opinion

10. In his First Inaugural Address as
President, Jefferson stated that the State governments are “the surest
bulwarks against anti-republican tendencies”–that is, tendencies which
conflict with the American form of government: a Republic.
He stated in a letter to Destutt de Tracy (1811): “But the true
barriers [bulwarks] of our liberty in this country are our State
governments . . .” With regard to the people’s freedom from
Government-over-Man controls by the Federal government, in keeping with
the Constitution’s limits on that government’s power, Jefferson stated
in his Annual Message to Congress, in 1801: “Agriculture, manufactures,
commerce, and navigation, the four pillars of our prosperity, are the
most thriving when left most free to individual enterprise.” In the
above-mentioned 1811 letter, Jefferson also discussed the prospective
use of the Militia of the States–all acting together–to resist the
forces of any Federal usurpers acting in violation of the Constitution
to oppress or dominate the people or government of any State.

Some Peaceable Remedies of the People Against an Offending Federal Government

11. Some of the peaceable remedies of the people of any State against
what they consider to be anti-Constitution, or otherwise offensive,
conduct by the Federal government–by any of its Branches, or by all of
them combined–as contemplated by the Convention which framed the
Constitution, were specified in The Federalist number 46 by Madison, with silent acquiescence of his co-author Hamilton, as follows:

“On the other hand, should an unwarrantable measure of the federal
government be unpopular in particular states, which would seldom fail to
be the case, or even a warrantable measure be so, which may sometimes
be the case, the means of opposition to it are powerful and at hand. The
disquietude of the people, their repugnance and perhaps refusal to
co-operate with the officers of the union, the frowns of the executive
magistracy [officials] of the state, the embarrassments created by
legislative devices, which would often be added on such occasions, would
oppose in any state difficulties not to be despised; would form in a
large state very serious impediments, and where the sentiments of
several adjoining states happened to be in union, would present
obstructions which the federal government would hardly be willing to
encounter.”

The most extremely “unwarrantable measure” is an unconstitutional
measure. Madison here expressed the understanding also of those who
framed the Constitution and of their fellow leaders in the State
Ratifying Conventions as well as of the people in general–all extremely
jealous of their hard-won liberties and determined to act vigorously
against any danger to them from the greatly feared, central government
if it should ever threaten to over-step the limits imposed on its powers
under the constitution, as amended. Protests by State legislatures
against what they would consider to be abuses of power or usurpations,
potential or actual, by the central government were of course included
as a main element in what Madison referred to her as “legislative
devices . . . impediments . . . obstructions.” Actual examples occurring
afterward are the Kentucky and Virginia Resolutions of 1798 and the Hartford Convention Resolutions of 1815 (discussed in Principle 3, Pars. 5-6).
Some additional remedies of the people, of a peaceable nature, are
political action–use of the ballot in elections–and amendment of the
Constitution by the people (Art. V); while impeachment by Congress of any officials guilty of acting as defaulting public trustees is provided for (Art. I, Sec. 2,3).

State’s Self-defense by Force, in Last Resort, per “The Federalist”

12. With regard to use by the States of force–use of their Militia
forces (all able-bodied males capable of bearing arms)–in self-defense
against any Federal usurpers seeking to oppress or dominate one or more
States by force in violation of the Constitution’s limits on Federal
power, Hamilton and Madison discussed at length and in detail in The Federalist (numbers 28 by Hamilton and 46 by
Madison) the assumption and expectation of The Framers that all States
would marshall their forces and act jointly to crush the usurpers’
forces. This understanding of The Framers was shared by the members of
the State Ratifying Conventions and the leaders and people in general of
that day–all fearless foes of any and all enemies of Free Man in
America. They believed that all true Americans must be ready to fight
and die for Liberty, especially against tyrannical Federal officials
who, as usurpers, violate not only the Constitution but also their oath
of office: to support the Constitution only. It was also
contemplated that any non-military force used by the Federal usurpers
would be countered by the States’ use of their own non-military forces:
Sheriff’s posses (posses comitatus) and any civilian police forces. (See also Par. 12 of Principle 5.)

The Civil over The Military

13. The traditional American philosophy requires, as a fundamental of
the system of checks and balances, that The Civil must always be in
complete control of The Military. The Founders and their fellow
Americans were painfully aware of the lesson of history that large
standing armies are, in peacetime, potentially dangerous to the people’s
liberties. In 1776, the Virginia Declaration of Rights,
for example, made this clear in these words: “. . . that standing
armies in time of peace should be avoided as dangerous to liberty; and
that in all cases the military should be under strict subordination to,
and governed by, the civil power.” Another, related element in the
system of checks and balances is the requirement of the Constitution (Article VI) that all Federal officials–both civil and military–take an oath to support the Constitution [only];
with the result that all military officers, thus controlled
fundamentally and supremely by the Constitution, must be obedient to the
civil authority–chief of all the President–but only as to orders which
are not violative of the Constitution. The Military are, therefore,
obligated by the Constitution not only to refuse to obey any orders of
Federal usurpers–automatically made by the Constitution itself null and
void from the start–but to support the Constitution only, at all times
and under all circumstances, as the sovereign people’s fundamental law.
State officials, civil and military, are likewise so required to take an
oath to support the Constitution of the United States–meaning, in part,
to resist Federal usurpers by all necessary means: by force in last
resort.

The Conclusion

14. The truly American formula, in accordance with the traditional
philosophy, for sound and enduring self-government by means of
constitutionally limited government with adequate protection assured for
Individual Liberty, is this: Limited and Decentralized for Liberty.

Related

Filed Under: Historical, The 12 Principles

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Primary Sidebar

Post Archive

Site Index

  • About Me
  • Important Historical Documents
  • Recommended Links for Topic Research
  • Recommended Links on Religion
  • The 12 Basic Principles
  • The 28 Great Ideas

Post Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Genesis Sample on Genesis Framework · Powered by WordPress.com. · Log in