• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Dealing With the World Today

A personal blog on the world today and dealing with it as a Christian.

Principle 10 – Private Property: Liberty’s Support

March 8, 2020 by Jim Vaughan Leave a Comment

The Principle

1. The traditional American philosophy teaches that Man possesses the
right to property as an indispensable support, the principal material
support, of his God-given, unalienable rights (notably the right to
Liberty) specified in the Declaration of Independence.

Part of Economic Liberty

2. This right to property is a main part of economic liberty, which
is the inseparable and indispensable aspect of the indivisible whole of
Individual Liberty, according to this philosophy. Without economic
liberty, the other parts of Individual Liberty are lacking in material
support and therefore, for practicable purposes, cannot be defended
adequately or securely enjoyed enduringly. This right to property in any
form–money or any other type–includes all aspects such as acquiring,
using, possessing, protecting and disposing of it. Man’s unalienable
right to Life necessarily involves his derivative right to property, in
support of his right to sustain his own life and the lives of his
dependents; which requires, in part, acquiring and using food and
various other kinds of property necessary to existence or conducive to
full enjoyment of God-given, unalienable rights in varied and
innumerable ways.

The Underlying Reason

3. The American philosophy teaches that the fact that Man is endowed
by his Creator with the Right to be self-governing, as the Declaration
of Independence proclaims, means implicitly that Man is also endowed
with the capacity to reason and, therefore, with the capacity to be
self-governing–under a system of Man-over-Government–for the better
protection and enjoyment of his unalienable rights. This, in turn, means
necessarily that Man is endowed with the capacity of being economically
self-reliant and independent, without the need of being supported by
his creature and tool: government. This is true because to be supported
by government would mean to be subject to its control under a system of
Government-over-Man; control inevitably accompanies subsidy. As part of
his Divine endowment at birth, Man therefore possesses both the right
and the capacity to manage his own economic affairs, including his own
capability to work in order to support life and his rights in general by
acquiring property (money or any other type), free from any degree of
Government-over-Man control, directly or indirectly. Any contrary
conclusion would inescapably, condemn Man to a birthright of servitude
to government, which philosophy rejects as being inconsistent with
Divine Creation. This philosophy also teaches that Man is entitled to
enjoy this right and to exercise this capability without any
interference by others than government as well. The foregoing is
subject, of course, to due respect for the equal rights of others and
for just laws expressive of “just powers” (to quote the term of the
Declaration of Independence) designed to safeguard the equal rights of
all Individuals.

The View of The Framers, per “The Federalist”

4. The American philosophy is clear and emphatic on the point that
the surest way for Man to become economically dependent upon, and
therefore subservient to, government is for it to control or possess his
property, or to subsidize him. This is because of the truth stated in
The Federalist (number 79, by Alexander Hamilton) that: “In the general
course of human nature, a power over a man’s subsistence amounts to a
power over his will.” (Emphasis Hamilton’s) This truth is also commonly
acknowledged in the maxim that “he who pays the piper calls the tune”
and it applies especially to a person’s income.

The Means of Self-defense

5. This is all the more true to the extent that government controls,
or takes from him, his property–not only his current earnings, or
income, but also his accumulated savings represented by his property in
general. The more government controls or takes from him, and the less
Man possesses and controls, the worse his plight in the face of
Government-over-Man practices infringing his unalienable rights. This
deprives him of the means of self-defense, of defense of his rights,
against violations by government and by others. Lacking such means, his
rights are always in danger of being violated or undermined with
impunity by transgressors–either oppressive or usurping government
officials, or covetously inclined persons who are disregardful of the
limits on their own equal rights and are heedless of the duty factor of
Individual Liberty-Responsibility, which requires them to respect the
equal rights of others.

Property Needed for Defense of Man’s Rights

6. According to the American philosophy, Man’s purpose in creating
governments is primarily “to secure”–to make and keep secure–his
unalienable rights, as the Declaration of Independence phrases it. A
chief aim of man in this regard is to provide governmental (legal)
machinery which can be readily available to each Individual for
establishing and maintaining his legal right to his own property and for
the equal protection of all Individuals’ property under equal laws
(basically the people’s fundamental laws–their Constitutions, Federal
and State). To be able to make effective use of this legal machinery,
however, Man needs property (money) to pay the cost.

The 1776 Declaration and the Word “Property”

7. In the years leading up to the American Revolution of 1776, the
slogan of the “Sons of Liberty”–most ardent of patriots–was: “Liberty
and property.” Another popular phrase used throughout America in that
period to describe Man’s most precious rights, used for example in the
“Declaration and Resolves of the First Continental Congress” in 1774,
was: “life, liberty and property.” This combination of ideas–expressed
with regard to protection of Man’s ” . . . life . . . person . . . goods
or estate . . .”–appeared in America at least by 1641 in Massachusetts
in: “The Body of Liberties.” This was a law code compiled by Nathaniel
Ward, in response to public protests against the arbitrary decisions by
judges, and adopted by the Massachusetts General Court, the legislative
body of the colony. In the phrase of the Declaration of Independence
adopted in 1776–“Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness” – the
substitution of the phrase “the pursuit of Happiness,” in place of the
word “property” customarily used theretofore, assuredly did not mean
that the signers of the Declaration disapproved of the idea of the right
to property being considered a most important right of Man. Quite the
contrary is true, as all pertinent records amply prove. A number of
these signers were owners of large and valuable property holdings–for
example, John Hancock, Thomas Jefferson, Robert Morris, Charles Carroll,
Richard Henry Lee and Arthur Middleton, to name only a few. They did,
indeed, risk great fortunes, as well as their lives and honor, in
signing the 1776 Declaration–as its closing pledge made express, in
words made immortal by the exemplary selflessness, the noble
self-sacrifice, of these true friends of Independence for America and of
Man’s Liberty against Government-over-Man. The wealthy of that
generation were fully matched by those of little or no means, such as
Samuel Adams, in the fervor of belief in, and support of, the right to
property as a fundamental part of the Individual’s rights. It is
noteworthy that among the signers of the Declaration were some who had
been members of the above-mentioned First Continental Congress in 1774;
and all the signers undoubtedly shared the then popular support of the
slogan: “Life, Liberty and Property” as being expressive of the gist of
Man’s fundamental rights. The emphasis in their thinking regarding the
right to property was later reflected in the safeguarding provision
included in the “Bill of Rights” amendments to the United States
Constitution–in the Fifth Amendment, stating: “. . . nor shall private
property be taken for public use, without just compensation.” This is
expressive of the American philosophy.

The omission of the word “property” from the 1776 Declaration was,
presumably, because the right to property was considered by America’s
leaders in general to be not a primary, God-given, unalienable right–not
on a par spiritually with the right to “Life, Liberty and the pursuit
of Happiness”–but an essential legal right, a most important supporting
right as the material mainstay of Man’s unalienable rights including
Liberty against Government-over-Man.

An Essential Means, Not an End in and of Itself

8. The right to property is accordingly considered not an end, in and
of itself, but an indispensable means needed to sustain Life itself and
for the protection and fuller enjoyment of the rights to Liberty and
the pursuit of Happiness. The right to property is, therefore, of
critical importance to Free Man, whether considered as a supporting
right or–as some in 1776 occasionally referred to it–as an unalienable
right, a Natural Right.

The concept of the property right being derived from every
Individual’s natural right to Liberty–of its thus being a derivative
right rather than a primary, God-given, unalienable right–was expressed
for example in an oration in Boston on March 5, 1775 by Dr. Joseph
Warren, a leader among the more prominent workers and fighters for
Liberty and Independence, as follows:

“That personal freedom is the natural right of every man, and
that property, or an exclusive right to dispose of what he has honestly
acquired by his own labor, necessarily arises therefrom, are truths
which common sense has placed beyond the reach of contradiction.”
(Emphasis added.)

Warren and his fellow leaders in favor of “Liberty and Independence,”
in Boston especially in that pre-1776 period, were undoubtedly in
agreement on this point of derivativeness: “necessarily arises
therefrom”–notably Samuel Adams who was very closely associated with
Warren in supporting this cause. Adams presumably meant nothing
different when he sometimes referred to the right to property as being
of the nature of a “Natural Right.”

Property Supports Ideals

9. Man’s right to property is the principal material support of the
idealism of the traditional American philosophy–the idealism of Free Man
in America. This idealism would be empty of substance in the absence of
the protection provided by such support; it could not be translated
into reality and sustained enduringly.

The Conclusion

10. The American philosophy asserts that Man’s right to property is a
main, indispensable and inseparable part of the indivisible whole of
Individual Liberty-Responsibility and the material mainstay of his
unalienable right to “Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.”

Related

Filed Under: Historical, The 12 Principles

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Primary Sidebar

Post Archive

Site Index

  • About Me
  • Important Historical Documents
  • Recommended Links for Topic Research
  • Recommended Links on Religion
  • The 12 Basic Principles
  • The 28 Great Ideas

Post Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Genesis Sample on Genesis Framework · Powered by WordPress.com. · Log in