• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Dealing With the World Today

A personal blog on the world today and dealing with it as a Christian.

Instrumental Music in Worship

March 8, 2020 by Jim Vaughan Leave a Comment

Much has been written on this subject. However, there are many who
only became Christians in recent years. Children are growing up who are
not acquainted with the discussions of yesteryear. Our minds dim with
the passing of time. It is right to stir up your sincere minds by way of
reminder (2 Peter 1:13; 3:1).

Some would dismiss the subject as relatively unimportant. I suppose
Cain thought it was relatively unimportant how he sacrificed, but God
thought otherwise (Genesis 4:5; Heb. 11:4). Nadab and Abihu no doubt
thought it was relatively unimportant when they offered strange fire
before the Lord, which He had not commanded them (Lev. 10:1). God
thought otherwise. We could multiply such examples. It is important to
worship as God has commanded.

Many times sincere people have asked me why I think instrumental
music is wrong. I do not think instrumental music is wrong. Let me
illustrate: I do not think there is anything wrong with beefsteak. In
fact, I would enjoy beefsteak if I could afford to buy it. If, however,
beefsteak were placed on the Lord’s table together with the bread and
the fruit of the vine, that would be sinful. Instrumental music is not
wrong, but its use in worship is wrong because God has not authorized
it.

True worshippers “worship the Father in spirit and truth” (John
4:23). Only by the word of God can we know how to worship in spirit and
truth.

Paul said: “I will pray with the spirit, and I will also pray with
the understanding. I will sing with the spirit, and I will also sing
with the understanding” (1 Cor. 14:15). By faith — based on the word of
God (Rom. 10:17) – I can pray in the spirit. By faith I can sing in the
spirit. But where in the New Testament does it say that one can PLAY AN
INSTRUMENT IN THE SPIRIT?

We must worship in truth. What is truth? Jesus said: “Your word is
truth” (John 17:17). To worship in truth we must worship sincerely and
we must worship according to the word of God. Where does God’s word say
that any church of Christ used a mechanical instrument in worship?

God seeks worshippers who worship in spirit and in truth. The use of
instrumental music in worship is not based on God’s word. Such worship
is therefore not in spirit and it is not in truth.

When is worship Scriptural?

Anything is Scriptural for which there is a direct command. The
Lord’s Supper is Scriptural because Jesus said: “Do this in remembrance
of Me” (1 Cor. 11:24). We have a direct command.

A thing may be Scriptural because it is authorized by an inspired
example. We meet on the first day of the week to break bread (Acts
20:7). A comparison of this passage with other Scriptures indicates that
this example was based on apostolic teaching.

We may conclude that a thing is Scriptural if there is a necessary
inference, if it is authorized indirectly as an essential part of a
command or inspired example.

Nowhere in the New Testament is the use of instrumental music in
worship commanded. We have no approved example of its use. There is no
necessary inference that it was used. Most of those who use it today
freely admit that it was NOT USED in the New Testament church.

What about PSALLO?

There are some who contend that the use of PSALLO in the Greek New Testament makes instrumental music Scriptural.

If PSALLO means to play an instrument why do Greek scholars translate
it as ‘sing’ in our New Testaments? If PSALLO means to play an
instrument why did not the churches in New Testament times use an
instrument?

As I write, I have the Greek-English lexicon of Henry Thayer before
me. He gives definitions from various periods in the history of the
Greek language. First he defines PSALLO as used by Aeschylus (525-456
B.C.): “to pluck off, pull out…the hair.” This is obviously not the
meaning in the N.T. He then defines the word as used by Euripides
(480-406 B.C.): “to cause to vibrate by touching, to twang,” then as it
is used in the later Classical period: “to touch or strike the chord, to
twang the strings of a musical instrument so that they gently vibrate,
to play on a stringed instrument, to play the harp.” He says it is used
in the Septuagint (a Greek translation of the O.T. made between 325 and
150 B.C.) to translate words meaning ‘to sing to the music of the harp’
and also with the same meaning as in the N.T. (to sing). Regarding N.T.
usage he says it means: “TO SING A HYMN, TO CELEBRATE THE PRAISES OF GOD
IN SONG.”

Shall we take the Classical meaning, the meaning in the Septuagint, or the New Testament meaning?

The only definition of PSALLO which fits the context where this word
occurs in the New Testament is ‘to sing’: “and sing to Your name” (Rom.
15:9); “I will sing with the spirit, and I will also sing with the
understanding” (1 Cor. 14:15); “singing and making melody in your heart
to the Lord” (Eph. 5:19); “Is anyone cheerful? Let him sing psalms”
(James 5:13).

I want to include here a statement made by John W. McGarvey, one of
the best Greek scholars of the past generation. Listen to brother
McGarvey: “It is manifest that we cannot adopt the practice (referring
to instrumental music in worship) without abandoning the obvious and
only ground on which a restoration of Primitive Christianity can be
accomplished, or on which plea it can be maintained.” Let me say I
believe this with all my heart. So universal is the scholarship of the
world on this point that this illustrious scholar says further: “It is
universally admitted by those competent to judge that there is not the
slightest indication in the New Testament of divine authority for the
use of instrumental music in Christian worship.”

What about the Psalms?

Some contend that instrumental music is Scriptural because it is
mentioned in the Psalms. Those who so contend admit that we are no
longer under the law of Moses (Gal. 3:24,25), but, so they claim, the
Psalms were not part of the law, and therefore we are authorized to use
the instruments they mention.

If this be true then we, as Christians, are free to do ALL things
mentioned in the Psalms. David said: “Purge me with hyssop, and I shall
be clean” (Psalm 51:7). Is the use of hyssop Scriptural under the New
Covenant?

And what about the following? “Let the saints be joyful in glory; Let
them sing aloud on their beds. Let the high praises of God be in their
mouth, and a two-edged sword in their hand, to execute vengeance on the
nations, and punishments on the peoples; to bind their kings with
chains, and their nobles with fetters of iron; to execute on them the
written judgment – this honour have all His saints” (Psalm 149:5-9).

Does this Psalm authorize Christians to execute vengeance with the
sword? Jesus said that His kingdom is not of this world. If it had been,
His servants would fight (John 18:36). He also warned Peter: “Put your
sword in its place, for all who take the sword will perish by the sword”
(Matthew 26:52). In Revelation this warning is repeated: “He who kills
with the sword must be killed with the sword” (Rev. 13:10).

No, the Psalms were written under the Old Covenant and contain many things which are not applicable to Christians.

Jesus quotes from the Psalms as part of the law. “Jesus answered
them, ‘Is it not written in your law, “I said, ‘You are gods’”‘?” (John
10:34). This quotation is from Psalm 82:6. “But this happened that the
word might be fulfilled which is written in their law, ‘They hated Me
without a cause’” (John 15:25). This quotation is from Psalm 35:19. The
Psalms are part of the law.

May Christians worship according to the law of Moses? “But now we
have been delivered from the law, having died to what we were held by,
so that we should serve in the newness of the Spirit and not in the
oldness of the letter” (Romans 7:6).

Is singing required?

A friend with whom I contended over the issue of instrumental music,
as well as other things, claimed that the whole thing is a matter of
option, even whether we sing or not. According to him, instruments may
accompany the singing since singing is not necessary anyway.

Let us look carefully at this. Jesus said true worship must be ‘in
spirit’ (John 4:23,24). Paul said: “I will sing with the spirit” (1 Cor.
14:15).

How can singing be optional? We are commanded to sing both to one
another and to the Lord: “Be filled with the Spirit, speaking to one
another in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, singing and making
melody in your heart to the Lord” (Eph. 5:18,19); “Let the word of
Christ dwell in your richly in all wisdom, teaching and admonishing one
another in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, singing with grace in
your hearts to the Lord” (Col. 3:16).

Nor can one maintain that the use of an instrument is a matter of
indifference. Jesus said: “In vain they worship Me, teaching as
doctrines the commandments of men” (Matthew 15:9). How did the use of
instrumental music get into the worship? It is not found in the New
Testament. It was BROUGHT IN and it was TAUGHT IN by MEN. Jesus said –
and I believe it – that such worship is VAIN.

An innovation

A stream can rise no higher than its source. Both in earlier
centuries and in more recent times, instrumental music has been
introduced hand-in-hand with a general disregard for the authority of
the Scriptures.

The following was written in 1860. “So far as known to me, or I
presume, to you, I am the only preacher in Kentucky of our brotherhood
who has publicly advocated the propriety of employing instrumental music
in some churches, and that the church of God in Midway is the only
church that has yet made a decided effort to introduce it” (Franklin and
Headington, The Life and Times of Benjamin Franklin, p. 409-411). This
statement was made by Dr. L.L. Pinkerton about the introduction of a
melodeon a year earlier at Midway, Kentucky. This man also believed that
the unimmersed could be fellowshipped in the church (H. Hailey,
Attitudes and Consequences, p. 232).

The effort of some brethren to use the instrument and stop there is
doomed to failure. When one does not require Biblical authority for one
practice, he no longer has a valid defense against other unscriptural
innovations.

Is it an expedient?

This is the argument of most: There is no Scriptural basis for it,
but we use it as an expedient. IS IT EXPEDIENT? In the decades since the
instrument was introduced in America those who DO NOT use it have GROWN
FASTER than those who do, and large numbers of those who use the
instrument have gone into abject apostasy. This indicates that it is NOT
expedient to use the instrument, so these brethren can not justify
their practice by saying it is expedient.

Furthermore, this is an improper use of the word ‘expedient’. Before
something can be classified as an expedient, it must be authorized but
not specified. We are commanded to ‘go’ into all the world, but ‘how’ we
are to go is not specified. It may be expedient to fly. More often it
is expedient to travel by car. Sometimes it is expedient to go by train.
If the manner of going had been specified – if we had been told, for
example, to ‘go on foot’ – we would not be free to choose an
‘expedient’.

We have been commanded to worship. We have also been told HOW to
worship. Therefore we may not worship just any way we please. HOW we
worship is not a matter of expediency.

We have been authorized to ‘sing’ in our worship. In order to sing we
must in some way know what words to sing. This has not been specified.
Therefore, the use of songbooks is an expedient. It is a way of knowing
what to sing.

Instrumental music, however, is not a way of singing. It is not an
expedient of anything because it is a distinct act within itself which
has not been authorized. If the use of instruments had been authorized,
then it might be expedient to use an organ, rather than a piano. Since
instrumental music is not authorized, since it has no Scriptural basis,
it cannot be an expedient.

Playing an instrument is not an expedient way to sing. It is an
independent act. An expedient can only exist as an acceptable way of
doing something which has been authorized. One cannot ‘fly’ without
‘going’. A songbook has no function unless one sings. But an instrument
can be played without anyone singing. I have noticed when attending
churches which have corrupted the worship by the use of the instrument,
that they often spend as much time playing the instrument without any
singing as they do playing it along with the singing. How can it be an
expedient?

Conclusion

Many years ago we had a discussion with some of these brethren.
Various ones had spoken in connection with the subject but finally one
person said: “I like it, and to me it is worship.” I am afraid that is
the real reason for its use. I love these brethren and I would like to
be in fellowship with them, but they would rather have an instrument of
music in their worship than to have the fellowship of their brethren.
They LIKE it, so they do it, even though God has not authorized it, and
even though it causes division.

The instrument is a sign of a disease. To remove the instrument
without removing the condition of heart which makes its use in worship
possible, would not avail a thing. The disease would only break out in
some other way.

Brethren, let us worship God according to the New Testament. Let us
have Scriptural authority for all that we do and teach. Let us be joined
together in the same mind and in the same judgment (1 Cor. 1:10).

Related

Filed Under: Personal, Religion

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Primary Sidebar

Post Archive

Site Index

  • About Me
  • Important Historical Documents
  • Recommended Links for Topic Research
  • Recommended Links on Religion
  • The 12 Basic Principles
  • The 28 Great Ideas

Post Categories

Copyright © 2026 · Genesis Sample on Genesis Framework · Powered by WordPress.com. · Log in